Battle of the Factions

[Moderator]

11:50, 13th Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected

 

[Ironside]

Information:


As a Reviewer of the Map Reviewers Group, I joined the THW Cleaning Event.
I end up writing a fast review, or just posting the end state of the map, rating is not always included!


Current State for this map: Rejected


I will contact the moderator to Approve/Reject the map, depending on what you recieved.

 

[MaxFlax]

Why?

 

[-Kobas-]

I will explain that for ya!

Ok let see...

Bad things:
Player play with simple unit not hero
Bad because:
-No abilities (skill points etc)
-No icon for quick selection
-Stats
No game modes
No difficulties
Game Interface look bad
-Icons should have different border
-And you should change that descriptions (Divine beings take damage only etc etc)
No leaderboard or multiboard
No power ups
No items
No map preview or loading screen
No upgrades (stats/abilities and so on)

Is that enough or should I write more?

 

[Ironside]

Actually, I didn't even need to look at map, as your description breaks the rules anyway, but for what -Kobas- wrote, makes it even more Rejected...

 

[Darkzealot_128]

I recommend doing ALL of what Kobas says and this will be a decent map.

Check: Actually, I would have found this decent enough if you had more items, more upgrades, a map preview and loading screen, and a multiboard. Maybe even insert some random events.

 

[Peter Canvis]

Don't listen to these @*§, the map is actually decent, it just lacks the details, such as icons, loading screen, etc.

Rating is 4/5, no matter what these @*§ haters say.

 

[New-Godabortion]

Orginally posted by Peter Canvis
Don't listen to these @*§, the map is actually decent, it just lacks the details, such as icons, loading screen, etc.

Rating is 4/5, no matter what these @*§ haters say.

Is that a joke ?!
this map is only bad !
I can´t see any positive things !

Never let it be said that ...

If i can rate 1/5^^

 

[Hawk]

Don't listen to these @*§, the map is actually decent, it just lacks the details, such as icons, loading screen, etc.

Rating is 4/5, no matter what these @*§ haters say.

Reporting this post immidietly!

 

[-Kobas-]

Don't listen to these @*§, the map is actually decent, it just lacks the details, such as icons, loading screen, etc.

Rating is 4/5, no matter what these @*§ haters say.

I am not @*§, @*§ hater or whatever, I just try to help him!
There is no point to rate this map with 5/5!

I commented only about some BASIC stuff that ruin his map!
Should I comment about terrain, triggers, gameplay?

Think before posting, and try to improve your behavior!
This is not place for insulting!

Post Reported!

 

[Hawk]

Off - topic:
@-kobas- did you saw that picture ?

 

[MaxFlax]

Im new to mapmaking and I dont know every thing about it.
I'll improve it soon
Actually there is a gamemode
Whats wrong with the terrain and icons?

 

[Ironside]

Don't listen to these @*§, the map is actually decent, it just lacks the details, such as icons, loading screen, etc.

Rating is 4/5, no matter what these @*§ haters say.

You do realize that -Kobas- and I indeed do have a word here, since you're already reported, I don't have to do so myself, this is already the 2nd map today!

 

[-Kobas-]

Im new to mapmaking and I dont know every thing about it.
I'll improve it soon
Actually there is a gamemode
Whats wrong with the terrain and icons?

No problem dude I understand that!
I started just like you 2, just like anyone else...
But you uploaded map in bad time
We are cleaning THW from bad maps!

I commented bad stuff and added few suggestions!
Terrain is good but there are few errors that can ruin gameplay!
When time come I will check improved map and give more tips

 

[MaxFlax]

Thnx
Which errors? lag?

 

[-Kobas-]

Nope, pathing ground!

 

[light bolt30]

Use these BB Codes to help you improve the bad description. Terrain doesn't seem good from preview as well.

 

[-Kobas-]

I bookmarked this map also in my to do folder
As soon as I finish with rest and some other things I will write review for ya!

 

[MaxFlax]

Thanks =D