Azshara Island

[Moderator]

11:05, 23rd Apr 2014
Orcnet: See my comment

 

[eubz]

Nice terrain but I can't give full review for now, I'm on my phone.

 

[Go'el]

Nice terrain but I can't give full review for now, I'm on my phone.

Thanks! And no problem, I can wait

 

[Legal_Ease]

This is really small and doesn't have much going on. I don't see any special landscaping effects or interesting tile/doodad combinations. The temple in the center is cool but it doesn't really have much to it either. I guess it's not bad or ugly, just really too simple.

 

[Tal'Rarity]

I don't think this should be approved until it has a bit more added.

 

[eubz]

Map is nice looking but not that special. Can be used for small scale cinematic but cannot be used for other map genre because it is very small. If you are going to add some more units and other effects (doodads, props, etc) this will become crowded. I suggest you use UTM if you are going to submit a terrain template. As for this map, I guess rejection is my vote.

 

[Streak]

the terrain of the beach is cool and you can expand the area of the map which seems to help but i like the beach terrain and i bit useful on campaign maps and cinematic.

and a little bit out standing

 

[Go'el]

This is really small and doesn't have much going on. I don't see any special landscaping effects or interesting tile/doodad combinations. The temple in the center is cool but it doesn't really have much to it either. I guess it's not bad or ugly, just really too simple.

I don't think this should be approved until it has a bit more added.

Map is nice looking but not that special. Can be used for small scale cinematic but cannot be used for other map genre because it is very small. If you are going to add some more units and other effects (doodads, props, etc) this will become crowded. I suggest you use UTM if you are going to submit a terrain template. As for this map, I guess rejection is my vote.

I might change some spots, but I guess it will stay the same size, and if I add some things, won't be too much. Because, as I said in the Map Info, it's just a tiny and simple terrain, for short cinematics, like a conversation in a meeting point...
But I'll see. Thanks by the suggestion anyway

 

[Streak]

Rejection

 

[Go'el]

Updated.

 

[Heinvers]

just really too simple.

I agree.
Also it's quite small for a template. Anyway the terrain is a bit empty.

 

[SeedinAethyr]

When making a terrain template, you are making a resource for mapmakers to use in their maps. As with other resources, it needs to be useful. This template seems to have no uses besides for a cinematic interlude for a campaign. I strongly suggest you make this map bigger so you can increase its versatility.
The terrain doesn't even seem good enough to justify making such a small map. In my opinion, if a mapmaker is going to make a really small terrain template, it should have lots of work made into making the terrain feel immersive and breathtaking.

 

[Go'el]

Updated. And look, I know which that's too small for a template, I done this for short cinematics. And it's hard to please everyone, but if I want to please everyone, I would make a barbecue, not a template

 

[Heinvers]

hahaha. Yeah, I guess you're right

 

[Streak]

launch update! much more better now

 

[eubz]

Still the same size and not that much interesting. As I said before, you can use UTM for terrain templates.

 

[Go'el]

Still the same size and not that much interesting. As I said before, you can use UTM for terrain templates.

I saw this map, but I only imported 2 doodads from there. I don't really liked of all of those. And I don't understand what you said, you mean, make a template in this map?

 

[eubz]

You don't need to import models from it, you can use it for your terrain template.

 

[Go'el]

Ok, but honestly, I don't see any difference, but the next one I'll do on the way you are saying...

 

[eubz]

Ok, but honestly, I don't see any difference, but the next one I'll do on the way you are saying...

That would be a great difference in terraining if you use UTM. That one is mostly used by our great terrainers here.

 

[Orcnet]

This template is just, really small. I know it can fit well as a terrain template score but I'd rather suggest this fits as a practice source, for now it would be best if you can do better.

 

[Go'el]

Updated!

Edit - 11/9/14: Updated again.