Moderator
M
Moderator
19:50, 21st Dec 2013
Orcnet: fatal error, uh kinda need you to check it out.
Hell_Master Map approved with a rating of 3/5 based on SCN's review here:
StoPCampinGn00b: Though I'm not proud of my year old review, I've updated the moderator rating to what I feel it deserves. This may be the best American football map out there.
Orcnet: fatal error, uh kinda need you to check it out.
Hell_Master Map approved with a rating of 3/5 based on SCN's review here:
StoPCampinGn00b;2489626 said:Azeroth Bowl v0.55c
A worthy American Football map implemented into Warcraft 3
Gameplay: 14/20
Terrain: 7/10
Scenery: 3/10
Consistency: 5/5
Presentation: 5/5
Total Score: 34/50
Gameplay: Fel Orc Ravagers vs Ironforge Warriors: Ravagers 18-12! I played against my brother and I was glad there was AI. Without it, I don't think I would have reviewed the map. It's hard to get into it, at first I just didn't want to play for more than 5 minutes. I got used to it and the game was enjoyable.
The thing that bothered me while playing was that the camera was to low. It's hard to see where all of your players are, I don't want to stay still while throwing a deep pass.
Also, how the hell do you kick a field goal?
The game is creative and a successful attempt at implementing an American Football game in Warcraft, even though W.A.L.K already did it. The fun factor is there, and the game is balanced unless some of the teams have better stats then others. Using the special moves are hard, but keep em.
Terrain: Change the tiles order to make the white marble over the grass. There isn't much to say since it's just a shaven field, but you should also change the endzone to maybe grass trim for it to stand out better instead of it blending into the dark grass. Add some space between the football field and the black boundary, most maps should have a natural or man made border between them. I gave you 7/10 because this kind of map doesn't need nice looking terrain, but you can do better.
Scenery: This guy is just dragging your score down. It doesn't look or feel like a football game, it looks boring. I have a suggestion take out the black boundaries and the trees and replace it with an arena. Just use the city scape manmade cliffs with some chairs and villagers around and it will look cool. Make it seem like gladiator maps, it doesn't have to be fancy. Adding some NFL or sports music would make the game fantastic.
Consistency: I didn't see any bugs or fatal errors. Everything seems to work snap by snap.
Presentation: Nice customized description. It attracts attention and is organized to help people understand the map better. Credits listed.
Miscellaneous Suggestions:
-Change countdown "Hut Hut Hut", it's just weird.
-Consider moving the 2pt conversion a little closer
-Take out the two "super safety's" in the endzone. They don't have the in football and it ruins your taste when you are about to run a long way for the touchdown
-Make the yard markers shorter in length
-I doubt you'll change this, but the map in proportion looks more like a CFL (Canadian Football is a lot longer) field than a standard NFL field. Making it shorter won't make a big difference
3.4 average score, I vote for approval
Last notes: There is nothing in the map to stop it from being approved. I really think you should a stadium and zoom out the camera but all rules and requirements are met (http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/rules-information-710/map-submission-rules-228244/). +rep to OP
EDIT: WAIT! You need to state if the map is locked or not.
Review by SCN
StoPCampinGn00b: Though I'm not proud of my year old review, I've updated the moderator rating to what I feel it deserves. This may be the best American football map out there.