Archipelago vs. Grave_Digger_

[Archipelago]

Hello Moderators!

I want to challenge Grave_Digger_ in a spellcreating challenge!

The Hive Workshop
Challenge Request


Challenge Theme:

Spellmaking (Same same Gilles -.- )

Challenger:

Me, Archipelago

Opponent(s):

Grave_Digger_

Challenge Duration:

5 days

Proposed Reputation Award:

10 Points

Challenge judging:

redscores

Map-specific conditions:
Theme:

Make a fitting spell for a melee hero.

File size:

No specified limit here...

Imports allowed:

No imports

Optimization/protection:

Not neccesary...

Other:

Only, GUI and no imports

Model-specific conditions:

File size:

N/A

Polycount:

No imports

Other:

N/A

Texture-specific conditions:

File size:

N/A

Other:

Other challenge conditions:
Details:

Since I know that either Grave_Digger_ or me makes spells normaly it would be fun to see what we can make.

About Juding;
50% Theme (About how much the spell fits for the hero)
5% Icon (How it fits the spell & hero)
20% Triggering
20% Coolness (How cool and nice it is )
5% Name (How good the name fits both spell and hero)

 

[Gilles]

I'm not the best speller, but I'm fairly proficient with the English Language. ; )

I'm guessing you are referring to a spell making contest, not a spelling contest. I would recommend using someone else as a judge. I can find leaks, and use a bit of GUI, but I'm not qualified to judge contests.

 

[redscores]

Well, i am not a moderator, but is it possible that I could judge? you know, I am well known as spellmaker and system creator.

 

[Archipelago]

Will it start when Grave_Digger_ accepts now?

I'm not the best speller, but I'm fairly proficient with the English Language. ; )

I'm guessing you are referring to a spell making contest, not a spelling contest. I would recommend using someone else as a judge. I can find leaks, and use a bit of GUI, but I'm not qualified to judge contests.

Yeah yeah, spelling - spellmaking. Same same but different

Well, i am not a moderator, but is it possible that I could judge? you know, I am well known as spellmaker and system creator.

Ah, good. Sure if your good you'll be the judge then
I'm editing the head-post. . .

 

[Grave_Digger_]

I'm in! When do we start? Gilles, is it getting approved?

 

[Gilles]

Set a start and finish date, and I'll approve this.

 

[Archipelago]

How about;

3rd may - 8th may. Is that okay with you grave?

 

[Grave_Digger_]

How about;

3rd may - 8th may. Is that okay with you grave?

That'll be just fine

 

[Gilles]

I'll try to remember to move it then. If I don't PM me and I should move it within that day.

 

[Grave_Digger_]

Now here's my entry.

 

[Archipelago]

Now here's my entry.

And here's mine ...

 

[Grave_Digger_]

Sadly for me, here are the scores (judged by RedScores);

redscores Rating:

100 Points can be reached.

Scale:
80 - 100% = Very good
60 - 80% = good
40 - 60% = not too good
20 - 40% = bad
0 - 20% = WORST!

[Archipelago]

Theme: 50/50 (matches the brewmaster perfectly)

Icon: 5/5 (just a perfect matching icon for this spell)

Triggering: 3/20 (HELLISH leaks, more as 6 point leaks and 3 group leaks in the Spell Start

and in Storm, Earth and Fire triggers as a whole 9 location leaks... and this spell is not

MUI, I would say 3 for a halfway complicated spell)

Coolness: 10/20 (pretty cool for a spell, but not too original... well...)

Overall: 68/100 = 68% = good.

Name: 2/5 (hm, primal strike... matches not really the spell..)

[Grave_Digger_]

Theme: 30/50 (Fire with a bug? doesn't match a cryptlord )

Icon: 1/5 (why a crypt fiend as icon for a mass parasite swarm with fire effect?)

Triggering: 10/20 (simple... 16 location leaks per cast, nothing too impressive... easy

triggering...but MUI... because of no waits)

Coolness: 10/20 (nothing too cool about it... but it has a good visual effect.)

Name: 3/5 (matches the spell good, beside the fire effects)

Overall: 54/100 = 54% = not too good.

Archipelago wins.


redscores

Edit: When you read this Gilles, give archipelago his price . . . But I wanna win some time too!