(1)Desert Siege v1.00

[Moderator]

» Vengeancekael:[c] 「Profile :: Message :: Hive Staff」

» Date:[c] 「09/Mar/2013 13:55:03」

» Reasons:

​

​

» Comment:

Verdict + Critter idea + Events + Custom spells - Custom spells don't exactly go together - Generic defense map - Polishing (Colorization, inconsistent tooltips)

Have I ever told you how bad that font you always use for loading screen is?
Don't spam the screen with millions of timers, just put them all in a multiboard.
Colorize in-game text (not completely, just keywords) for better readability.
"Abetter" has missing DIBTN. Oh and it's not active.
The Far Seer's spells don't really seem to go together, ice shards, summoning wolves??
Every spell tooltip is written in a different style.
Arrange the items in "Upgrader" properly, put the same ones next to each other.​

​

Acceptable

[tr]​

» Rules: [c] 「Map Submission」

» Contact: [c] 「Staff Contact」

_{! 'Reasons' are automated !}

 

[eubz]

Any comment or review is well appreciated.
Development: http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/map-development-202/1-desert-siege-227569/#post2264184

 

[UgoUgo]

Since the map is small, you could try polish the terrain using UTM models?

 

[Orcnet]

my Review

hope for the good changes and good luck!

 

[eubz]

Map updated.

 

[SeedinAethyr]

Oh my god chubemocboc... octuple post. The moderators will kill you... There is an EDIT button for a reason!
Back to the map.
Desert Siege is a singleplayer hero defense in which the player must kill the demons attacking. Periodically, a demon will be sent disguised as a critter to reach the circle of power. The concept is okay, but the map is quite short, and the abilities, while not regular Warcraft 3 abilities tweaked (except for Feral Sprit), they aren't the best. Abettor seems like a very OP single target spell. It allows critters in the beginning to be easily killed, and the Doom Guard killed without much of a fight. The battles against the attacking demons weren't special in any way. They had decent health and damage. They provided gold when killed. Some of them cast spells, but I'd really like to see a semi-boss thrown in with the regular creeps with good looking spells. Defending the base is pretty bland, even with the critters added in. Also, once you kill the Infernal, you become invincible. You should reduce the stat gain to like thirty, not one hundred. Plus, you have around one to two waves to show off your stats. I'd like a longer game with more items, cooler enemies, and more events.
3/5

 

[eubz]

Oh my god chubemocboc... octuple post. The moderators will kill you... There is an EDIT button for a reason!
Back to the map.
Desert Siege is a singleplayer hero defense in which the player must kill the demons attacking. Periodically, a demon will be sent disguised as a critter to reach the circle of power. The concept is okay, but the map is quite short, and the abilities, while not regular Warcraft 3 abilities tweaked (except for Feral Sprit), they aren't the best. Abettor seems like a very OP single target spell. It allows critters in the beginning to be easily killed, and the Doom Guard killed without much of a fight. The battles against the attacking demons weren't special in any way. They had decent health and damage. They provided gold when killed. Some of them cast spells, but I'd really like to see a semi-boss thrown in with the regular creeps with good looking spells. Defending the base is pretty bland, even with the critters added in. Also, once you kill the Infernal, you become invincible. You should reduce the stat gain to like thirty, not one hundred. Plus, you have around one to two waves to show off your stats. I'd like a longer game with more items, cooler enemies, and more events.
3/5

Thanks for this. I will be updating this when I have time.

 

[deepstrasz]

-Abbetor has no DSTBN
-demon critters should become stronger later on or at least faster
-100 to all attributes? Is this a cheat?

Feels like this map could use a lot more love.

2.5/5.