09:20, 6th Sep 2013
enjoy: Well, though it's pretty good, and you did a nice job, this is just a replica of CRAZYRUSSIANs icon. He made the tutorial so that you could practice, but you aren't really supposed to upload the icon, if it's just a replica of the tutorial. This isn't useful, because CRAZYRUSSIAN already made it, and his version is better. Rejected.

nice but i think its maybe too blurry

I like the style however it feels like it still needs some work 3.5/4 (4)

You did very well, but you could have been a little more original on your design and not just follow the one in the tutorial since, this one, I think has already been submitted.

EDIT: http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/icons-541/btncrtesticon-93861/?prev=u=CRAZYRUSSIAN&r=20&page=16

Looks, nice, the colors are okay, but if I were you, i would add brighter colors to it. Keep it up.

This looks very nice and the icon comes in a lot of different apperences so you can use it for every situation, however it does look a bit blurry so I'm going to give it a 4/5.

The icon has a great BG which fits with the main and highlighted chakram. I give you points with that. The BG is quite creative. Though what bothers me is that the energy (is it?) emmited by the chakram is like a solid substance that should not be and should be gas substance or somehow like that.

Overall, I give you still 4/5 and +4 REP for this great work.

Very nice! 4/5 +rep

I would say looks much more like a fire/wind wheel than a chakram
ref, Chakram: http://roleplaying.xenaholic.com/Weapons/xena_chakram_2_larger1.jpg
ref, Wind/Fire Wheel: http://www.kenfuderyu.co.za/images/...heel Of Wind And Fire - Lun - Ring - Huan.jpg

but I guess that's fair enough given the shapes you -can- get for them, eitherway - Looks pretty decent, not sure how I feel about uploading tutorial-type icons (i.e. given direct instruction to draw it) particularly when we effectively already have this icon, but I suppose it is different enough to be allowed through, the blurring is a bit of an issue though 3/5 in my opinion.

I feel blind but this reminds me of those Halo swords.