15:47, 30th Dec 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Useful

Why are the corners black? Make them red as the Box is.
Also it needs more shading and its too monotone (the box), make some golden whirls or somethin alike...
However the good thing is the light, coming from inside the Box... its nice
but for now 2.25 / 5 :/
Improve this and the other Teal Box one (my review for it is the same).

EDIT: Changes made... now it looks better the other one too
4/5 and vote for approval

On top of it i see some white pixels who doesn't fit, even though i think it could be useful to someone

It's too dull. The Magic box has no shine. It also doesn't seem "Magical". Put some magic in it.

updated

Can you end the bottom on a place where it can be seen on the icon, because it looks like some cylindrical object, not a box.

like that?

Yep exactly what I mean. It starting to look pretty good, and it's definitely much better than your first.

anything else i could do?

I'm not sure. Ask a moderator. Maybe a bit more shading.

looks really nice
4/5