Approved
Moderator
M
Moderator
Vengeancekael - [Contact]
Date: 2012/May/28 17:25:36
Comment: [Approved]
Quick reviewin' time!
First off, the terrain can't really be judged, it's just a small arena, but I would suggest you add different arenas to make the map fresher, because it can get very boring rather quickly.
Next up, the map needs a lot of balancing and while I like the idea of having those special skills that you charge up by either typing a sentence quickly (Archmage) or by casting it 4 times, the cutscenes get too repetitive and boring and you should either remove the idea of these extreme skills so that you can focus more on tactics and quick control.
There are also some very huge bugs like the Archmage, after having cast my R (the extreme skill), I deal some damage and after about 3 seconds of the cutscene there are effects everywhere and my opponent just dies even though I didn't do anything else.
The skill icons should be replaced with fitting ones for each spell, so that the player has an overview of what the skill does, because the tooltips are way too short and lacking and you don't even give the player prep time to learn his skills and there's no tooltip about the hero in hero selection, just the name.
It also needs more modes, the killing can get really boring and also because of the long cutscenes, so you should find ways to mix things up a little.
Overall, it can be fun for 2-4 minutes, then it just becomes annoying, frustrating because of the balancing and the repetition, so add more modes, different types of arenas, better tooltips for both skills and heroes and new icons.
Rating: 2/5 - Lacking
Other suggestions:
Resource Moderation - Rules
Date: 2012/May/28 17:25:36
Comment: [Approved]
Quick reviewin' time!
First off, the terrain can't really be judged, it's just a small arena, but I would suggest you add different arenas to make the map fresher, because it can get very boring rather quickly.
Next up, the map needs a lot of balancing and while I like the idea of having those special skills that you charge up by either typing a sentence quickly (Archmage) or by casting it 4 times, the cutscenes get too repetitive and boring and you should either remove the idea of these extreme skills so that you can focus more on tactics and quick control.
There are also some very huge bugs like the Archmage, after having cast my R (the extreme skill), I deal some damage and after about 3 seconds of the cutscene there are effects everywhere and my opponent just dies even though I didn't do anything else.
The skill icons should be replaced with fitting ones for each spell, so that the player has an overview of what the skill does, because the tooltips are way too short and lacking and you don't even give the player prep time to learn his skills and there's no tooltip about the hero in hero selection, just the name.
It also needs more modes, the killing can get really boring and also because of the long cutscenes, so you should find ways to mix things up a little.
Overall, it can be fun for 2-4 minutes, then it just becomes annoying, frustrating because of the balancing and the repetition, so add more modes, different types of arenas, better tooltips for both skills and heroes and new icons.
Rating: 2/5 - Lacking
Other suggestions:
- Fix/remove the custom soundtrack, it's been converted or the quality has been lowered badly, because there are a lot of annoying noises in between
- Also lower the music volume, it's way too loud
Resource Moderation - Rules
| Reasons: Other: If you have any complaints or questions directed towards a moderator, make a thread here: Map Resource Moderation If you think the moderator's judging is unfair or you have overall complaints, make a thread here: Admin Contact Please read the rules thoroughly: Rules Comment: Map works, no horrible bugs or anything. Approved for the time being, review coming up soon. |
