Space Orcs vs. Zombies 1.8X

[Moderator]

Orcnet

17:53, 3rd June 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved

Space Orcs vs. Zombies (Version 0.6) Rate Score Percent Letter 5/5 91-100 A Rate Score Percent Letter 4/5 81-90% B Rate Score Percent Letter 3/5 75-80% C Rate Score Percent Letter 2/5 70-74% D Rate Score Percent Letter 1/5 50-69% F Overview: Gameplay "Space Orcs vs. Zombies" is a 12-man player map based on a defense/survival theme. "The game is outstanding, ranging from just a small map with enough defense specs is superb no much problems have been found during the game-wise." Terrain "Terrain is tight and very small, but it would be best if you can give some tile variations or some outlandish environment mixed with fellwood's poisonous design." Management "Overall its quite a good map with no much bugs found after the end of the game, the random pick when a user finishes the timed peon is cool, to my conclusion very useful and recommended for defense players and all." Total Score: Rate Score Percent Letter 10/15 83% B

 

[David]

Heres my review:

Good:

It was so fun to play and it is balanced.
The spells are well designed and well picked.
Everything is functional.
Good and clean details.

Bad:

This is not so needed but you could have added some pits where they spawn and some dead trees somewhere.

My vote: 3/5 Vote for aproval.

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Thank you for your feedback!
I will add new enemie types like spawn pits in the future but I have not so much time at the moment

 

[David]

Thank you for your feedback!
I will add new enemie types like spawn pits in the future but I have not so much time at the moment

I am glad I helped

 

[Orcnet]

map approved, see details on top

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

map approved, see details on top

Thank you very much for the aproval and review

Please tell me about any bugs and balance issues you found and which level you reached so that I can fix it

 

[Binsu]

It is so weird. There is only one forces so I cant start the game......

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

It is so weird. There is only one forces so I cant start the game......

Hotfix Incoming

 

[Binsu]

Now I really wonder how you guys did play it if there is only has one forces and in LAN it is unplayable.... maybe all of you played it in Single.

And I am interested on your map so just tel me if you fixed that issue and I'll play it and give my review.

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Now I really wonder how you guys did play it if there is only has one forces and in LAN it is unplayable.... maybe all of you played it in Single.

And I am interested on your map so just tel me if you fixed that issue and I'll play it and give my review.

It must be working right now, I wonder that the map was not rejected

 

[Binsu]

They played it in Single Player I guess.

 

[David]

They played it in Single Player I guess.

The maps work absolutely great, orcnet already gave a review also and yes we tested it in single player.

 

[Binsu]

Well, my SP is not working very well and for unknown reasons it always give me fatal error on each of maps I played so I can only test things in MP.

And the problem here is it is unplayable in MP but now the author has said fixed, I will be playing it now and give a review later.

 

[David]

You can also test everything in the world editor

 

[Binsu]

Oh ok, well I just did play it in SP even in MP and it is quite hard but maybe playing with frends will change it so here is my review:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain looks good but yu could have add some more doodads and some decors because it is so empty. There is nothing bad on adding and also you should have decorated more the spawning points like putting some amazing special effects on it.
-Great heroes. Heroes serves their purpose well in battle and they have custom skill and not just original and old plain Warcraft 3 skills.
-A balanced game with balanced creeps and heroes.

[-] Bad Points:
-None

[] Suggestions:
-Just some minor improveents such as adding doodads and some decors. Also add some amazing special effects at the spawn points to make it attractive and not just plain Poisonous Tiles and to be honest, you should change that Poisonous tile to somewhat a dark and deadly tile such as maybe blight and add Blighted Mists and special effects.

Overall, this really a good map with somehow decent to good terrain. Rated 3/5 and +4 REP to you.

Cheers and happy mapmaking!

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Oh ok, well I just did play it in SP even in MP and it is quite hard but maybe playing with frends will change it so here is my review:

[+] Good Points:
-Terrain looks good but yu could have add some more doodads and some decors because it is so empty. There is nothing bad on adding and also you should have decorated more the spawning points like putting some amazing special effects on it.
-Great heroes. Heroes serves their purpose well in battle and they have custom skill and not just original and old plain Warcraft 3 skills.
-A balanced game with balanced creeps and heroes.

[-] Bad Points:
-None

[] Suggestions:
-Just some minor improveents such as adding doodads and some decors. Also add some amazing special effects at the spawn points to make it attractive and not just plain Poisonous Tiles and to be honest, you should change that Poisonous tile to somewhat a dark and deadly tile such as maybe blight and add Blighted Mists and special effects.

Overall, this really a good map with somehow decent to good terrain. Rated 3/5 and +4 REP to you.

Cheers and happy mapmaking!

thanks for the review and sorry for the starting trouble, i also think that I sould lower the difficulty again

 

[Binsu]

Lol, you TRIPLED not only double post. You should dleete your other two posts to avoid being neg REPPED =)

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Lol, you TRIPLED not only double post. You should dleete your other two posts to avoid being neg REPPED =)

:O cant find the third one

 

[Orcnet]

just make a dummy force 2 to make your map playable in LAN, or convert all of those hostile creep waves into a enemy computer player

 

[Binsu]

Well, he did already make it like Host then Players. =)

 

[Orcnet]

oh lol okay then

 

[~DARK~]

For This Map Terrain Is Good But If You Make The Barracide Betters And More It Will Good

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

For This Map Terrain Is Good But If You Make The Barracide Betters And More It Will Good

Hmm yes but i have no clue how to do this

 

[FullVisor]

such a good map... can you add the sentrygun or something?

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

such a good map... can you add the sentrygun or something?

I am glad that you like the map
What do you mean with the sentrygun? The Engineer already has an ability that creates one

 

[FullVisor]

I am glad that you like the map
What do you mean with the sentrygun? The Engineer already has an ability that creates one

my mistake...got sentrygun ability on engineer.

 

[alexmantor]

man the cool models are of him, I know. But besides that theres Triggering, terraining, stuffs... your defense map is bothering similar to mine

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

man the cool models are of him, I know. But besides that theres Triggering, terraining, stuffs... your defense map is bothering similar to mine

Wait what?! I get the feeling that you are trying to troll me.. In your map you have to defend a little fortress which contains clifffs, walls, towers and stuff, while my tarrain is entirely flat. By playing your firebat class i noticed that your heroes have not many complex trigger spells and very different spells at all... your map has a storyline+cinematic, mine not ... so please come up with some valid arguements.

 

[Binsu]

Looks like this is just a wrong judgement I guess..... btw, Calcium whats up with the map?

I hope your doin good with it and expecting for more updates!

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Looks like this is just a wrong judgement I guess..... btw, Calcium whats up with the map?

I hope your doin good with it and expecting for more updates!

Thank you Hell_Master
map is going well, I try to add more complexity to it step by step (At least 3 more classes and enemy types to go). At first I have to find some fresh ideas for the next update

 

[Binsu]

Nice, looking forward. =)

 

[Orcnet]

man the cool models are of him, I know. But besides that theres Triggering, terraining, stuffs... your defense map is bothering similar to mine

That's a silly argument your trying to pull, The idea(let's add title, concept, genre, mechanics, ORCS vs. Worlds) has already been seen from past years, if you could do your time you can scour the approved "Shooting FPS, Modern Warfare" related maps with Space Orcs in it.

Now in this case, This map has entirely different game feature but has same objective "survive enemy waves till reach last level", game-wise it has no terrain(yours does), start of the game you picked out a hero in a tavern(you picked a hero in a dialog trigger), it has quest menu(you have none).

Totally speaking, everyone makes up ideas like this, its not special or anything and no stealing bravado has come to this work. We are all humans afterall.

 

[Binsu]

Well said, genius =D

 

[Bloody Wolf]

kinda hard to play solo but i managed to enjoy it and MAYBE found a minor bug/glitch with the turret since it lets me build a turret in top of anything i whant

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

kinda hard to play solo but i managed to enjoy it and MAYBE found a minor bug/glitch with the turret since it lets me build a turret in top of anything i whant

Thanks for the feedback!
Yes, I think I have to lower the difficulty again. I am not sure about that turret thing, I will investigate it for the next update.

 

[Binsu]

Hey, there, bro. Just thinking, I noticed your games terrain to be empty and I didnt even suggest something to improve it so here:

If you want to make your terrain more haarder and requires careful building of walls or crates, you can add some doodads, destructibles or decors to improve terrain and at the same time, it will make the players think twice before build spamming crates. Will it block areas or such questions will come.

 

[jonhysone]

Good idea , +rep .
I loved enemy tho lol

 

[Destination9747]

It is the first time I have seen your map
I cant find any "bads" from the game!
But I recommend you to reduce the first timer...
I played as a single player and really i was going crazy with that!
+Rep

 

[IlsNt.RiTz]

Nice Map! I Love it

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Thank you all for your feedback

 

[Templar890]

It was so fun to play it...4/5

 

[Bloody Wolf]

yo calcium are you planning on updating this?

 

[IleftBecauseHadReasons]

Seems even better that I thought. It's actually fun to play!
In most games of this type I tend to pick 1-3 heroes which I like, because others are boring... it's not an issue here, every single orc is entertaining and well planned.

Bug:
- Sniper's Bio Weapon skill instead of slowing zombies - speeds them up.

Suggestions (mine, so not really creative):
- Add a few more items, just a few :3
- Maybe Firebat should have some small splash passive damage? Just to finish wounded enemies around without sometimes wasting AoEs.

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Seems even better that I thought. It's actually fun to play!
In most games of this type I tend to pick 1-3 heroes which I like, because others are boring... it's not an issue here, every single orc is entertaining and well planned.

Bug:
- Sniper's Bio Weapon skill instead of slowing zombies - speeds them up.

Suggestions (mine, so not really creative):
- Add a few more items, just a few :3
- Maybe Firebat should have some small splash passive damage? Just to finish wounded enemies around without sometimes wasting AoEs.

Thanks for the feedback and the suggetions . I will implement them in the next version! I also plan to rework the sniper entirerly, since I don't really like how he plays at the moment.

 

[Mr.Pockets00000]

This shows much promise. I'll have to download it and put it on my bot. I'll have to host it with my palls sometime.

 

[Acutesharpness]

Hard mode in single player is actually playable xD

 

[Calciumcarbonat]

Hard mode in single player is actually playable xD

Yeahh maybe I overdid it with lowering the difficulty. Which level did you reach?

 

[Acutesharpness]

I played hard mode and fucked up buying two barricades and barely kill the pudge but as it goes it could be till second boss.

 

[ToastAddict1057]

The AI is dumb as hell .3.

But theres 1 thing i can say: I'm addicted to dis map.

4/5