Harry Potter Maul v2.0

[Moderator]

15:18, 2nd May 2009 by bounty hunter2:
I need proof that you had the permission to edit the map, other than that:

- Poor terrain
- Poorly written tooltips
- Typos

Rejected.

 

[Paradosi]

Comments are greatly appreciated and bugs/imbalances etc are also appreciated.
Enjoy

 

[Jack_Sparrow93]

Well, I have no Harry Potter feeling when I play this... Its just name and there are better models that can be used... Its useful but not more... 3/5

 

[busterkomo]

This is my review of Harry potter Maul v2.0.

Pros:
-Imported music gave the map a great harry potter atmosphere.
-Large selection of "Races" and towers. I use the term race loosely because you don't choose your Race, per say.
-You clearly state you're not the original author; you merely edited the map.
-Periodic tips are great help for newer players.
-Little to no bugs.
-Can be very fun if played with 12 players.

Cons:
-"Pheonix" is spelled wrong on the loading screen.
-The leaderboard could be improved in terms of cosmetics.
-A very generic TD.
-Terrain was rather boring. Very lacking in terms of tile and height variation (save for the blizzard cliffs). It's worth noting that the use of blizzard cliffs is perfectly fine in Tower Defenses.
-The sell ability has a missing tooltip.
-Where do "The Forces of Northrend" fit in with HP lore? You should rename to something such as Death Eaters.

Rating: 2.5 (translates to 2.0) and Recommended for approval.