Guardian

[Moy]

Cartoonish. Add more depth to it, make it more 3D. And try different shades of color for a nice touch and texture. It also lacks details. This I can say to be a base, it is good for replicating the reference, but it needs more for the hive. Add more originality to it by adding ornaments or whatsoever. The background seems also distracting. This however, a great work it just needs a little tweaking and it'll be good. Good job and good luck.

 

[Roland]

I really like the reference compared to your work tbh.

 

[Chaosy]

As far as I am concerned this is a sweet looking icon which would beat anything I'd submit in art class.

However the style is too cartoony to fit with Wc3 in my opinion.

 

[Rheiko]

Cartoonish. Add more depth to it, make it more 3D. And try different shades of color for a nice touch and texture. It also lacks details. This I can say to be a base, it is good for replicating the reference, but it needs more for the hive. Add more originality to it by adding ornaments or whatsoever. The background seems also distracting. This however, a great work it just needs a little tweaking and it'll be good. Good job and good luck.

Thank you for the feedback, sir.
I will do my best. ~

I really like the reference compared to your work tbh.

That's understandable, tbh.

As far as I am concerned this is a sweet looking icon which would beat anything I'd submit in art class.

However the style is too cartoony to fit with Wc3 in my opinion.

omg, is that a compliment?
I will try to make it more 3D then

 

[jhonwaa]

This very nice

 

[GhostThruster]

~nightmare pretty much hit the nail on the head, though you can definitely replicate a reference picture if you wish (no tracing though :3).

my feedback, which is a bit more specific:

• the lighting of the armour is actually fairly nice, if only because it defines a clear light source. i'd suggest you use hard brushes for shading. this adds detail and texture to the metal, whereas right now it looks incredibly clean and smooth. don't forget about shadows too!
  
• don't define form via black outlines, use shading and tonal variation instead. many beginner icon makers - including myself long ago - did this. all it does is make your icon look flat, and it doesn't fit with blizzard's art style.
• the background is messy and simplistic.

awaiting update.

 

[Sin'dorei300]

There's no update for some time now. If you plan to update this icon, let me know.
Moved to S/TS section.

 

[Aleister]

The image looks like A work professionally drawn, by paint.
But don't get discouraged bro, keep practicing!

 

[Rheiko]

Updated. I re-draw the Icon from the scratch. And this is the outcome, I hope it's an improvement.

Before:	After

I don't know why the system considers two resources as one resource. I tried to delete one but the system will detect it as "no resource"

but anyway, I hope I can get feedback. ~

 

[Diegoit]

Wow, very nice icon
-Unit?
-It has white glow? or is a mistake?.

 

[Rheiko]

Well, I don't know what's the best color for it since I don't want it to be so distracting, so I just gave it white.
Any suggestion?

 

[Diegoit]

Well, I don't know what's the best color for it since I don't want it to be so distracting, so I just gave it white.
Any suggestion?

Remove it , with that white glow it look more like a spell instead an unit.

 

[Rheiko]

Updated.
Removed the white glow.

 

[Daffa]

The question is, when to use this icon?

 

[Panda]

Simple but could be useful.