Moderator
M
Moderator
This isnt a copy, it is different. Back to pending.
Please get rid of the white lines around the bracers.
You can also take upon THE_END's previous statement on matching the hues of the other trolls, then again trolls hue's dont always have to match due to their linage. But I do suggest it but don't mind if you don't take upon it. I like how you have smoothened the face out.
Fix:
*The lines around the bracers.
*Possibly get rid of the metal/brace/grey armour on his waist, it looks rather weird on the model and doesn't seem to match.
*Add more detail to the tusk, but that's optional.
*Maybe add abit more highlights since it still looks abit bland, adding highlights/gloss can make things popout more easily and look shiny. Id kinda expect some gloss due to his bulking muscles and sweat. Have a look and see what you think when you try.
Kim EDIT: Oh.. and make sure it has teamcolour, I also hope my edit was not drawn over or such in the process of this new version.
Kim EDIT 2: I have had a talk with another skin mod and he believes you have drawn over my skin, I am suspicious but not sure and would prefer evidence than opinion, and as such I do not have much evidence to give you a clear and true record. I will send this into rejected until updated until we have more words with the other mods and can come to a mutual agreement and conclusion. I am very sorry for the problems coming from this and hope you will be patient.
In the mean time, please try making alot more freehand additions of the skin so the freehand (if it was a draw/smudge over) can be truly qualified as your work if the previous case is true.
Please get rid of the white lines around the bracers.
You can also take upon THE_END's previous statement on matching the hues of the other trolls, then again trolls hue's dont always have to match due to their linage. But I do suggest it but don't mind if you don't take upon it. I like how you have smoothened the face out.
Fix:
*The lines around the bracers.
*Possibly get rid of the metal/brace/grey armour on his waist, it looks rather weird on the model and doesn't seem to match.
*Add more detail to the tusk, but that's optional.
*Maybe add abit more highlights since it still looks abit bland, adding highlights/gloss can make things popout more easily and look shiny. Id kinda expect some gloss due to his bulking muscles and sweat. Have a look and see what you think when you try.
Kim EDIT: Oh.. and make sure it has teamcolour, I also hope my edit was not drawn over or such in the process of this new version.
Kim EDIT 2: I have had a talk with another skin mod and he believes you have drawn over my skin, I am suspicious but not sure and would prefer evidence than opinion, and as such I do not have much evidence to give you a clear and true record. I will send this into rejected until updated until we have more words with the other mods and can come to a mutual agreement and conclusion. I am very sorry for the problems coming from this and hope you will be patient.
In the mean time, please try making alot more freehand additions of the skin so the freehand (if it was a draw/smudge over) can be truly qualified as your work if the previous case is true.
Kimberly-25/6/10:Sorry for the massive delay, finally had access to the dl which contained the proof (as it was down/not working at the time). I also would like to state it was not me who sent this back to rejected until fixed AFTER you updated that and am personally abit annoyed no proper notification from the person who did that wasnt stated here.
Since the skin has been updated, is of good enough quality to be approved and after all the drama and updates, I will approve it. I am sorry for the mess and delay and wish to apologize personally for the dilemma and hope this doesn't put you off on being a texturer. Thankyou.
As for people comparing this skin to the ice trolls, Jungle trolls can come in alot of different type of hues and shades, however in wc3, the ice troll is TEAL (tinted with green) and not BLUE and this skin is BLUE.
edit: fixed a typo in the moderation review. I meant "rejected" and not "pending" in reference to "pending until fixed"