Dear Deer

[Moderator]

13:55, 12th Oct 2008
Septimus: Resources rejected under the guidance of mini-mod.

[+] Scanned for viruses.
[+] Contains no errors that crashes the map.

Not good, it was basically just the Lordaeron Summer grass tile over the all map. Here and there you could see some grass doodads, but they looked out of the place at most locations. The water was square-ish, flower / shrub spam at some places. Your terrain, it did not contribute anything good to your map as it just ruins the feeling to have bad terrain, as it gives the feeling that you, the author didn't take time to finish, but rather rushed it.
-- 1 / 5 --

OK, 1 wolf was easy, 3 wolves was harder, as it should be. However, 1 wolf was very easy, whilst 3 wolves wasn't that hard either. You should've done something more creative to the different difficulties rather than just more wolves.
-- 2 / 5 --

Though I haven't played anything just like this, I have seen similar maps. It seemed like a cat and mouse scenario in singleplayer mode. I did not find this that original, mainly because there is so little that could be original in the first place.
-- 2 / 5 --

This wasn't fun at all, as basically all I did was run around right clicking at different places on the map. Should have random events and more things going on overall, such as your deer having abilities etc. Also, this map has no replay value what so ever, since it wasn't fun even the first time.
-- 1 / 5 --

This map contained neither the elements of fun, enjoyable or replayable. I think this map seems rushed, and it also seems like it is your first map, that is an explanation, yes. But no more reason for us to put it in the database. There are lots and lots of more work that needs to be put in this before it could get approved. My vote as mini-mod goes to dis-approval of this map.
-- 1.5 / 5 --

 

[D.O.G.]

Nice map! Very fun to play. I like how you made secret. It isn't easy to win with 1 wolf, but survive with 3 wolves is not really. Anyway, great minigame.

 

[silver_fight]

Thank you D.O.G!!!!

 

[Linaze]

[√] Scanned for viruses.
[√] Contains no errors that crashes the map.

Not good, it was basically just the Lordaeron Summer grass tile over the all map. Here and there you could see some grass doodads, but they looked out of the place at most locations. The water was square-ish, flower / shrub spam at some places. Your terrain, it did not contribute anything good to your map as it just ruins the feeling to have bad terrain, as it gives the feeling that you, the author didn't take time to finish, but rather rushed it.
-- 1 / 5 --

OK, 1 wolf was easy, 3 wolves was harder, as it should be. However, 1 wolf was very easy, whilst 3 wolves wasn't that hard either. You should've done something more creative to the different difficulties rather than just more wolves.
-- 2 / 5 --

Though I haven't played anything just like this, I have seen similar maps. It seemed like a cat and mouse scenario in singleplayer mode. I did not find this that original, mainly because there is so little that could be original in the first place.
-- 2 / 5 --

This wasn't fun at all, as basically all I did was run around right clicking at different places on the map. Should have random events and more things going on overall, such as your deer having abilities etc. Also, this map has no replay value what so ever, since it wasn't fun even the first time.
-- 1 / 5 --

This map contained neither the elements of fun, enjoyable or replayable. I think this map seems rushed, and it also seems like it is your first map, that is an explanation, yes. But no more reason for us to put it in the database. There are lots and lots of more work that needs to be put in this before it could get approved. My vote as mini-mod goes to dis-approval of this map.
-- 6 / 20 * 100 = 30 --

0-9 - Unacceptable
10-19 - Awful
20-29 - Bad
30-39 - Not Good
40-49 - Mediocre
50-59 - Okay
60-69 - Good
70-79 - Great
80-89 - Awesome
90-99 - Director's Cut
100 - Sub-Zero