First off almost all rts games have "basicly stand in one place and shoot at each other". I honestly think it would suck any other way. If they ran for cover at all times, you could never control your army. Second, you say only graphical improvements? Have you even read this thread? Did you read the last post? There are so many new things.
Improving graphics is usually why people make sequels to rts games. They don't have story, so there's only gameplay and graphics. Now why in the hell would Blizzard take an amazing game and totally revamp the gameplay? I personally want another remake of sc, with new units and graphics, not gameplay.
Are you kidding me? You just complained that sc2 was only 25% new gameplay, and then continue to say that Halo2 is a great example of sequal that isn't same old? You just stated all the things that were new to Halo2, and that's only 1, 2, 3 new things! Sc2 has five times the amount of new stuff. By the looks of things, DoW2 is going to be almost an entirely new game compared with the old DoW, and yet you say Halo2 was a better sequel content wise? Wow......
You dont even controle your army anyway, if you can make them get in cover that would be controling them wouldn't it.
Gameplay makes all the difference, graphics just make it look better, why play a game just becuase it has nice graphics, gameplay has to be real damn good too.
SC 2 has 5 times new stuff? realy?
Goliath-->Viking, viking can turn into retarded looking plane.
Battle cruiser only has a new ability, Still same buildings, just a few new addons.
Infested Terran-->Banling, now its gonna be like in C&C, suicidal runs doing shit loads of damage to your base.
Dragoon-->stalker
Archon-->twilight archon
Vulture-->cobra
Firebat-->Reaper, now they have cheap ass det-packs.
Thor and Immortal is new, few new unit abilities.
Looks too much like warcraft 3.
Rock paper scissors gameplay:
Immortal > Seige tank : Immortal < basicly everthing else
Cobra > thor, only if you circle it which you will never beable to do in a big battle.
i think you get the idea.
for DOW they need to add something big, maybe put in different game types n stuff.
and halo 1 to 2, lets see...
Warthog didn't get changed to new unit or anything, marines have driving AI, You can now drive wraiths, Covanant dropships are now phantoms, duel weilding, you can hijack vehicles, and of course, you got Drones and Brutes. AND YOU GET TO FIGHT FOR THE COVANANT AS THE ARBITER!!!
big difference i'd say.
if you wanna continue argueing about SC 2 make a new thread, i'll argue bout it.