BTNWizard

[Moderator]

09:05, 9th Aug 2012
Apheraz Lucent: The face angle is very bad, tilt it to the front a little. The whole icon lacks light sources and shadows, and appears very blurry due to the lack of outlines and color variation.

Rejected until updated.

 

[Coaster_Man]

Pretty good, but you need some more shading and highlights, 1/5 for now. If you add those things I said and maybe some more detail (I think he should have a big, twirly moustache) then it would be 5/5 easy.

 

[Narandza]

The shape is nice, all you need to do now is shade it, also highlight it but not too much, try watching some tutorials on how to do it.
I also give 1/5 +rep but I won't press the rating.
Anyway this icon has potential, but what is it used for? Is there a fitting model?

 

[GhostKnife]

For my first of anything like this you're all quite critical. I guess it's only good for me.

Anyway this icon has potential, but what is it used for? Is there a fitting model?

Yes, actually I did base this off this model.