BTNWarcryv3

[Moderator]

23:59, 25th Jun 2011
Pyramidhe@d: I would prefer if you used your skills to make an icon completely from scratch rather than drawing over something.

 

[Slead]

Look good

 

[hashveen]

it is bit cartoony but nothin's wrong with that..

 

[Marcos DAB]

+ Nice shape

- Not highlights
- Its too cartonish

 

[Adaethus]

I definitely agree with Marcos DAB, this icon needs some highlights and shading.

 

[Deolrin]

Ahem... By "credits to Bilzzard for the original icon", you mean that you just recolored it and drew the helmet? :/
Well, it is copy-and-paste, and as such will be rejected.

 

[Skipper]

Deolrin, Dota have Recolored and little changed icons.

 

[-Berz-]

I believe this icon is made for dota? Anyway, it's not bad, it juts looks to clean to fit in wc3.

 

[Darkfang]

Ahem... By "credits to Bilzzard for the original icon", you mean that you just recolored it and drew the helmet? :/
Well, it is copy-and-paste, and as such will be rejected.

He drew a helmet, changued the eyes, his skin, the shape, the only thing he needs is to add highlights, else this icon is his icon. the only thing he didnt changue was the bg

 

[Deolrin]

And the actual shape and oultine of the icon, yes.

 

[carlvic]

i saw this thread so i posted mine in here...
he just gave the priest a cloak.
http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/icons-541/btnmonk-193982/?prev=search%3Dmonk%26d%3Dlist%26r%3D20

 

[Ketsuno Anson]

Ahem... By "credits to Bilzzard for the original icon", you mean that you just recolored it and drew the helmet? :/
Well, it is copy-and-paste, and as such will be rejected.

Well,this could be approved,but its just too cartoonish,from what I see it's not recoloring,the definition of recolor means he just overlay it with another color,but this has its own shading and stuffs,the bg is really just a small part of the icon.

 

[Hades17]

The eyes need to shine/glow in some way, background could be more redish-purple else, kinda okay for a CNP rework. 3/5