BTNTheMapDraw

[Moderator]

14:41, 20th Feb 2009
Paladon: Changes made, keep it up. The rating tends between useful and recommended.

 

[Firelord213]

It Might look like Leather yes, Maps can be drawn on leather as well >_>

 

[bounty hunter2]

Old Review

Well to start off, here are some positive sides:

- The paper looks nice [√]
- I like the X marks the spot thing ^^ [√]

Negative sides:

- Black background, I know it's hard to find a fitting one for a icon this kind but just black is :/ [X]
- The feather looks bad, it doesn't have lines on the middle like a feather should have, take a look at this: Feather [X]
- The feather is to glowing [X]

I dunno it is a nice idea, but you should work more on it, I think 2/5 is enough, and your work is improving, growing to a 3 soon, I hope.

Good luck ^^, bounty hunter2

Positive sides:

- The paper looks nice [√]
- I like the X marks the spot thing ^^ [√]
- The feather looks much better now[√]
- A background other then black [√]

Negative sides:

- I couldn't actually find any now, looks great [√]

In the conclusion, I change my rating to a high [4/5], it isn't stunning and some great work, but it looks nice the way it is. Good job and good luck ^^, bounty hunter2

 

[Firelord213]

And Updated again

 

[Karouk]

Hm, I think it would be useful for like, a spell where you could see part of a map for a certain amount of time... OH OH! OR!!!!

You buy it as an item and you can spot the certain area for unlimited time

 

[Super-Sheep]

The feather returns.

 

[Leeroy]

Firelord, really nice icon. Simple but really, really effective. 4/5.
Also a background different from black and the X on the map is a nice idea.
Good job.