BTNStealSword

[Moderator]

02:09, 12th Jul 2010
enjoy: The icon is VERY blurry. It lacks definition, proper shadows, and the background could use alot of work. It needs to be defined from the background, as well. It seems like you placed the shadows and highlights in just one place, which makes it seem very flat. As suggested by the users, I suggest you take a look at the guide they posted. Rejected.

 

[crimson fire]

First to post =P looks good but I think you should change the backround to another color or something. the swords grey and so is the the backround and maybe zoom in a little on the sword.

 

[Kla0005]

Updated - Is it better now?

 

[chilla_killa]

The sword looks very round and spherical.
Maybe you should take a look at this:
https://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/2d-art-tutorials-281/basic-icon-guide-166366/

 

[Panda]

Its too blurry and the sword needs proper shading.

 

[gaby-boy]

Nice! 4/5