BTNSimpleBow

[Moderator]

10:32, 29th Sep 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Useful

 

[Jaret]

Umm... I dunno about this icon. It's too... empty. around 80% of it is black. These are the icons that need effects, or maybe zoom a little, change the perspective/view?

 

[Golden-Drake]

small stars:

will this be better??

 

[Goolygot]

Those stars didn't look good with the bow.

 

[Jaret]

you could scale the wood a little, and move the "rope (Or how the fuck's it called)" a little towards the wood part. Then maybe add some other effects, like a glow (Which it needs.) Look at other people's works around here. Here's a link to most bows on THW. Good luck with this icon

 

[Golden-Drake]

tried to fill out some space:

 

[Jaret]

Umm, again the same bug. Delete the second post. OK, so... Well, it is actually a little more "filled" and well, I like it. But still you should consider a background IMO, it would look better i think. Here's an example what i was thinking about (Something like this):

 

[Panda]

Nice updates, upload that!

 

[Mainy]

Icon Review	Status:
Idea 9/10 Freehand 9/10 Background 8/10 Shading 8/10 Ligthning 10/10 Total: 44/50	4.4/5 High Recommended

Much better after updates.

 

[Golden-Drake]

will make a BG then but it ruins my plans of a simple bow...

 

[Jaret]

Ok, so... Well, you should still add the background, but darken it. It shouldn't be noticeable if you want to make a simple bow and arrow: (This is Kola's icon)

 

[Golden-Drake]

Updated

 

[Goolygot]

BTN is still the same. But the DISBTN is changed, and it looks awesome.

 

[Jaret]

Ok, seems better now. But it looks (For me) like JPG instead of something else... I don't know hao to explain. It looks a little "Smooth" (In the bad way). Maybe it's because of my pc's graphics :/

 

[Ganondorf]

Ok, so:
1. IT looks too blurry. Make some black outlines to the bow and arrow.
2. The color is kinda too... reddish. Maybe you wanted to make some in particular wood, there's a lot of them. If not, hue it a little more to this icon's color (original creator: Kola):

3. The background's too... ordinary. You could change it to some other color, maybe color it red, or purple/violet.
Bottom line: This icon has got great potential. 3/5 rating. After the up stated facts are done, i would rate it 4/5. So, it is Approve-able at this state. You don't have to do the up stated facts, though. It is good as it looks like now.

 

[xDeathKnightx]

Good Icon, 5/5.

 

[Craiglionheart]

Nice icon, I like it