BTNShoreline

[Moderator]

09:03, 20th Jun 2009
zombie2279: Now this is one random icon. I don't see how this is a shoreline, it pretty much looks like a brown blob meeting a blue blob. The shore itself is not that bad, but the blue seems to be taking pretty much the whole icon, and I have to say it doesn't really look like water at all.

I recommend reworking the whole icon as seen on this picture:

Shoreline

Also, I'd like to ask you to post your icons at the forums before posting them here, preferably work in progress. You will obviously get more feedback if you post up your wips and will actually succeed in getting something well done. You will have to give iconing more effort than this.

 

[a7xpwns3]

I don't know why BLPConv is screwing up so much...
It flips all icons upside down in the normal version for some reason...

 

[Panda]

Quite original if i can say, but you might wanna fix up the hillside a bit. Maybe add some rocks in front of it in the water.

 

[Dentothor]

i dont really know what this would be good for...
but otherwise it lacks a lot of shading and looks like brown and blue blobs

 

[OnkelManfred]

looks like done in about 5 min. add some rocks, some grass, make it alive! thats important for that kind of icon, but the current icon fails. and rework the DISBTN (its some kind of mirror image or something like that).

 

[a7xpwns3]

By the way, it's so blurry because of THW's paste system.

Here's the actual icon.

And thanks to all suggestions!
I'll download border manager and update it with the new version.

 

[Slaydon]

get Button Manager, makes it correct in 2 sec