BTNRoothammer

[Moderator]

07:59, 28th Dec 2011
Pyramidhe@d: Use the update button next time

also. My criticism is exactly the same.

Idea is great. Need to work on your rock a bit more. Try looking at how the maul icon on Warcraft was done and see if you can emulate it. Maybe put some cracks. Also, I think those are vines. The vines look a bit more 3D. Some shading and such are needed.

15 Jan 2012
Pyramidhe@d: No changes made

 

[cyniccynic]

I think it's much better then the previous one.
i hope this gets approved. )

 

[Skipper]

Nope, the previous were better

 

[cyniccynic]

reason ? why is it worse then the previous one?

 

[Skipper]

This looks unnaturally and plastic, and it is too much light

 

[Midnighters]

It is far too flat, and unshaded. It needs work. Add more definition and shadow/highlights to it.

 

[Golden-Drake]

make the vines bigger and add shadows to them.
and maybe darken the BG a little.

besides that nice idea.