BTNredcircle

[Moderator]

17:28, 4th Nov 2008
Hawkwing: No shading, no contrast, no approval.

 

[Silent_One]

Firstly, RedCircle wtf. It's blue? And, it's quite lousy, make it more special and, Blizzard already has one so that makes this one quite overrated. But still, make it perhaps more 3Dish and for gods sake change the background. Blue + Blue = Phailur. So, for a good red circle you need: RED, something that makes it stand out, change the background and put a little more time into it.

 

[ivandanny]

Okay, It has something weird .
The real color is RED

 

[Hawkwing]

No shadows and no contrast = no approval.

 

[FrIkY]

As Hawkwing said, no shadows no contrast

EL REJECTO!

 

[Paladon]

The blizzard version
1) If its based on this, theres not enough freehand.
2) If freehanded
---->Hawkwing/FrIkY/Silent_One
3) If the following is the real version

Okay, It has something weird .
The real color is RED

its the mirrored blizzard one.

 

[Traxamillion]

Do I need to say anything....?

 

[Hawkwing]

I remember the Blizzard one differently, though I could easily be wrong.

 

[Discipline]

as ugly as this example is, I still don't see why an icon needs shading to pass.... an icon is a symbol to represent something and I sure as hell didn't see shading in Starcraft's icons yet Blizzard and the millions of SC players still approved of them. (well okay, they did have some form of shadow, but you get my point. Sim bowl lick)

This does need contrast however, yet like mentioned earlier because War3 already has this icon it's kind of unnecessary.

redcircle did put a smile on my face tho, I haven't seen anything more blue submitted to date