BTNPaladinsGuide

[Moderator]

13:08, 19th Apr 2009
Paladon:

Creativity: 2/5
Quality: 4/10
Status: Rejected until updated
Comment: Appears very simple, lacks in shadings and looks too edged.

 

[i_mOck_death]

needs more shading(in lightning things and the sword handle thing(the yellow thing)) and looks to pixelized. but i do like that glare on the sword that looks good

 

[a7xpwns3]

Okiley dokiley, Imma work on it.
Thanks.

 

[Misha]

it looks pretty cartoony and.. bleh =/
you should completly rework it, put it on angle and do more realistic thunders.

Rating: 2.34/5 Lacking

~Misha~

 

[a7xpwns3]

Well, I meant for it to look flattish and cartoonish so... >_<

 

[i_mOck_death]

the lightning does need work and the handle of the sword looks metal and almost like a dagger as the handle to where you wouldn't want to hold it (in other words i think handle needs some changing)

But main priority atm is the lightning i think


Edited after update 2: I can see your trying but when u upgrade lightning try to make the lightning more jagged since lightning is quite jagged if you know what i meen.

if you need references you can look at some lightning icons and stuff like that just dont copy and paste those lightnings lol

 

[Misha]

Well, I meant for it to look flattish and cartoonish so... >_<

don't like honest and constructive critique? then don't post. simple >.>;;

 

[Zombie]

The sword really lacks detail, honestly, it looks like as if it was CnP'd from some kind of 2D platform game. The background is not exactly fitting either, you shouldn't cover the whole black area with lightning.

 

[CloudMax]

The sword lacks detail.
I dont like that it is flat, even if its suppost to, it looks stupid.
This icon will never fit in as a warcraft III icon.
The yellow part of the sword looks horrible, just a yellow line.

I got rejected when i made a icon out of my avatar, and it got rejected, i would get a little pissed if this dont get rejected when my did...
Anyway, back to reality. I vote 2/5

 

[Dentothor]

It looks like you made it with paint... i give it a 2/5

Well, I meant for it to look flattish and cartoonish so... >_<

And warcraft isnt really ssupposed to be cartoonish... unless you come up with skins for the gamplay borders (ex. Cinimatic borders, Backpack borders) then this icon would completley clash with the "realness" of the game.