BTNOnion

[Moderator]

12:22, 10th Mar 2012
Pyramidhe@d: This has no shadings

7 April
Pyramidhe@d: This still lacks proper shading. This doesnt look round.

 

[Hexcellion]

It's an onion. Could be useful, so I'll give it a 3/5

 

[rcshaggy]

I say it looks weird, but it would be useful.

 

[Hemske]

It looks rather flat.

 

[Nightcrime]

Nice very useful for my new upcoming map! *rated*

 

[NFWar]

It need general shading on sides to define the shape. It looks like leaf for me.

 

[Remixer]

Why is it red? Atleast here in Finland onions are white or abit yellowish. Well... Also it looks kinda flat.

 

[sPy]

Why is it red? Atleast here in Finland onions are white or abit yellowish. Well... Also it looks kinda flat.

Ever heard of red onions? It's the basic onion in Malaysia.


Anyway, Im kinda lost interest to update this one. Perhaps I will leave it rejected and update it someday.

 

[Remixer]

Ever heard of red onions? It's the basic onion in Malaysia.


Anyway, Im kinda lost interest to update this one. Perhaps I will leave it rejected and update it someday.

No I actually have not. :/

 

[Cakedog345]

Color is fine, but needs some more shadows and highlights (to give the impression of roundness).

 

[sPy]

Updated: Right

Please be aware that the quality of actual icon is better than this preview.

 

[Remixer]

Make the down right edges more dark and add some shine to the top left.