BTNOldPendant

[Moderator]

15:54, 9th Feb 2016
GhostThruster: the thick black outline around the pendant makes it look too cartoony. it's hard to tell what it is due to weak shading and the way you've drawn the silk cloth background makes the pendant look like a butterfly :/

13:25, 10th Feb 2016
GhostThruster: you uploaded the wrong btn file . for the rest, the pendant definitely looks better without the black outline, but the shading is still poor (might wanna use a ref pic like this to get a better idea of a pendant's texture & shading) and the background is now even more confusing than before. i recommend just keeping the background black, and maybe zoom out of the pendant a bit and give it a neck chain. but if you can get the idea of a silk background to work and look good, more power to you.

 

[San]

Hm,it looks dull for me

 

[Arad MNK]

It's not a disaster. Not bad. Actually can be useful for some unique items.

 

[KILLCIDE]

The style doesn't really match WC3, but it has a lot of potential.

On a side note, what is the stuff behind the pendant? It kind of looks like fur.

 

[N41]

Hm,it looks dull for me

It was supposed to look dull and old ;P

It's not a disaster. Not bad. Actually can be useful for some unique items.

Yup, for some old item lost in some dungeon for millenia or more

The style doesn't really match WC3, but it has a lot of potential.

Thanks.

On a side note, what is the stuff behind the pendant? It kind of looks like fur.

It was supposed to be green silk cloth .

Edit:

the thick black outline around the pendant makes it look too cartoony. it's hard to tell what it is due to weak shading and the way you've drawn the silk cloth background makes the pendant look like a butterfly :/

Hope it doesn't look like Butterfly any more

---------
Old Icon

Old Pendant