BTNMug

[Moderator]

20:14, 31st Jul 2009
Hawkwing: I'm sure you could make the mug look more cylindric, but it's not really a huge deal. Nice work.

 

[The Panda]

Nice idea, but overall color and shading kinda mixes together and cant quite see what it is.

 

[Coinblin]

You're right. It is pretty monotone. I'll work on that!

 

[bigapple90]

It looks more like a shell or something. a mug is a cylinder + a handle

 

[Coinblin]

They can also have lids. And if you look closely, it does have a handle. Although I know watcha saying. I'm trying to fix this one up.

 

[Archangel_Tidusx]

I would at least change the color of the tin that the foaming liquid is coming out of. It's hard to tell what the hell the icon is supposed to be. Try a brown or something.

 

[Midnighters]

This rating was done by Midnighters

Creativeness: 6/10
Usefulness: 9/10

Looks like the real thing at the moment? [X]

My rating: Lacking

Overall it's a nice Icon, although there are a few things that need to be fixed:

1. You need you define the brim of the mug, it all looks the same
2. You need to make the mug portion look round instead of looking like a wooden plank
3. you need to fix the Highlights and shading

All these recommendations are given to give it a better chance of being approved.

Midnighters

 

[Archangel_Tidusx]

Was that all necessary?

Also.. the icon is completely differnt now.. so my new suggestions are:

Make the wood a different color, and add some shading betweent the cracks. Then change the consistency of the foam.

 

[breebree123]

nice, but there is just something missing

 

[enjoy]

it looks alittle like a piece of wood with white candyfloss on???
the beer has to shine more, and have bubbles in it.

2/5

 

[supertoinkz]

to plain for myself, add a little pale orange color under the bubbles, this will serve as the beer

 

[The Panda]

U just added alot of foam..do something with all the foam.

 

[OnkelManfred]

you must highlight the mug. it looks too flat at the moment :/

 

[Coinblin]

Man, I tried adding highlights to the mug, but something I've learned is that wood does not reflect light well, so it just looks bad.

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Nice idea and nice icon. It's useful too. Gj on this one. 3/5.

 

[Shoko]

Great work! 5/5.