BTNMine

[Moderator]

23:16, 6th Sep 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Too cartoony.

 

[supertoinkz]

Very undefined. Add more definition.

 

[chilla_killa]

Too cartoony!

 

[Biojuju]

 

[Zanekok]

remove black shapes and it will be OK-maybe...

 

[crimson fire]

its a good idea, havent seen those before but its to cartoonish :/

 

[PetrKubelka]

good Icon and i agree with Zanekok

 

[Golden-Drake]

CARTOONISH - way to cartoonish

- also remove the Boom/glow to the ground it kinda blends with the background

 

[makai]

maybe change the mine colors will be better... too cartoonish....

 

[Panda]

Looks to me like a arm of a animal climbing too the top of a mountain and that is his arm pushing himself up. You need to define this.

 

[Zealon]

nice icon! finally somthing other than the goblin land mine icon, maybe you can make like an ordinary land mine later?

 

[Hemske]

Like most of us have said, i think removing the black borders and defining the mine and it'll be allright.

 

[Jaret]

Well, no need for me to say it too, since almost all of these suggested the same. And as army-of-pandas said before, looks like a paw of a bear climbing up some mountain... But much more cartoonish.
1. remove the black borders.
2. maybe change the colors of the mine.
3. maybe you could define it a little better with more shadings.
4. maybe make it more unique (It looks a lot like the goblin mine.) (Now i notice that was intentional, so screw 4 )