BTNMilkshake

[Moderator]

09:44, 21st Jun 2009
zombie2279: Try adding some more details, or making them more visible and a bit softening the strong, dark shading.

09:34, 24th Jun 2009
zombie2279: Yet again, very simple but otherwise not that bad. No improvements made, but it's approvable.

 

[The Panda]

Nice icon man, but the 'm' on the shake needs to be little darker so you can see it. but overall very nice

 

[Avex]

Coke + Fries = Good
Shake + Fries Good
Coke + Shake = Stomache Ache
Fries + Coke + Shake = Major Stomach Ache
Chicken Nuggest + Fries + Coke + Shake + BigMac = Death.

 

[a7xpwns3]

Mind if I test out my new reviewing template?

This icon has been reviewed by a7xpwns3. If you do not agree with this review, then please contact me through visitor or private message.

Creativity - 5/5

Quality - 4/5
Shadings - 4.5/5
Colors - 3/5
Metallic Look - N/A
Realistic - 3.5/5
Warcraftish - 2/5

Clearness - 4/5

Usefulness - 3/5

Overall - 4/5

I suggest making it look a lot more realistic and warcraftish. I also recommend mixing around the colors, as they do not fit the theme very well. The shadings were quite coode, but in my eyes a bit overused. Overall, I liked the icon though.

Not too useful, though.

You like?

 

[bigapple90]

Coke + Fries = Good
Shake + Fries Good
Coke + Shake = Stomache Ache
Fries + Coke + Shake = Major Stomach Ache
Chicken Nuggest + Fries + Coke + Shake + BigMac = Death.

thats why u stay away from mcdonalds and other fastfood joints

 

[breebree123]

ZOMG! nice icon! milkshake is what i love drinking! 5/5

 

[Remend]

A nice icon which is not so useful... 4/5

 

[KelThuzad]

The shading looks alittle weird, Try to add sharpness to the bottle and glow, just glow around it.

 

[expazatrix]

Wouldn't suit to be implemented into Warcraft, but still its a nice Icon.

 

[Rufus]

I want it! I want it now!