BTNMightAxe

[Moderator]

20:35, 10th Dec 2013
enjoy: Looks good. But could use some more definition. But useful, simple and nice.

 

[Razosh]

It looks good enough even though it's not the most interesting of icons it deffinetly fits into WarCraft III. It looks good but I'd like to see more borders for it such as UPG and ATC since both of them could deffinetly be used for this icon.

 

[stonneash]

It looks good enough even though it's not the most interesting of icons it deffinetly fits into WarCraft III. It looks good but I'd like to see more borders for it such as UPG and ATC since both of them could deffinetly be used for this icon.

Yeah I was planning to do ATC & UPG but when I tried them they didn't fit.

 

[Razosh]

Yeah I was planning to do ATC & UPG but when I tried them they didn't fit.

Didn't fit into where, the hive? If they were to large or small in size they could easily have been rescaled.

 

[stonneash]

Didn't fit into where, the hive? If they were to large or small in size they could easily have been rescaled.

No. I meant to say the border just didn't look good but since there is at least 1 person who would like to see that I'll update it ASAP

 

[Razosh]

No. I meant to say the border just didn't look good but since there is at least 1 person who would like to see that I'll update it ASAP

They look awesome it's great always great to see a large veriaty of borders it improves the model largely, I however do not feel that giving this a 5/5 is justified when it's simply an axe but I will change my 3/5 to a 4/5. Once again it looks awsome.

 

[stonneash]

They look awesome it's great always great to see a large veriaty of borders it improves the model largely, I however do not feel that giving this a 5/5 is justified when it's simply an axe but I will change my 3/5 to a 4/5. Once again it looks awsome.

Not to interfere with your opinion but i made this icon as simple as a basic axe so it can be used to most axes while I tried to keep it decent and good looking.

 

[Razosh]

Not to interfere with your opinion but i made this icon as simple as a basic axe so it can be used to most axes while I tried to keep it decent and good looking.

I'm not arguing with the quality of the axe but giving it the same rep such as models with as much detail as this one seems rather wrong.

 

[stonneash]

I'm not arguing with the quality of the axe but giving it the same rep such as models with as much detail as this one seems rather wrong.

the rating system is based on rating something depending on how good it is for what its representing, so an axe is rated for how good it is compared to how well the icon could be, and an air revenant icon is rated likewise.
it was made like this because if you looking for a 5/5 basic axe, you will find more options than usual.

 

[Sin'dorei300]

Looks nice, but needs a bit of zoom in and some kind of glow\background, imo.

 

[stonneash]

Looks nice, but needs a bit of zoom in and some kind of glow\background, imo.

I knew A glow would make it better but its just that I can't draw a good glow, If you look at all my icons I barely have any good glow on any of them and I didn't want to mess this one up with some weird looking glow.

 

[InfernalTater]

This looks very good, 4/5.

 

[Narandza]

Something you could improve:
A tiny zoom in, and the iron on the wood should be a little bigger.

Looks good and sharp, and shading seems right.

 

[Mike]

Very great looking axe.