BTNLostone2

[Moderator]

12:53, 13th Jan 2014
Kimbo: Sorry dude, but these icons are way too blurry/smudgy. Any chance you can update the details and make them looks more crisp, detailed and less flat? Try to avoid smudge as it tends to make things look unnatural, oily and blurry.
I will give you afew days to update the icons. (the lostone icons)

Edit: No update/response. Rejected.

 

[darkdeathknight]

Your Weapon could fill in the icon a bit more.

 

[Shadow Fury]

Ur 3 icons r very similar! All share some mistakes like black background and no glows. This icon could be left like that it's tier 1 weapon, but the rest must be updated with sharper edges and glows. For now, all get 2.5/5 from me and a rating of 2.
If u work on this icon too, it would be better.

 

[Apheraz Lucent]

I took a good look, and came to a conclusion that all three icons look like they're trimmed out of a screenshot icon, probably made within Warcraft. If I'm wrong, please show me the evidence that you drew this by your hand.

I hope you'll take a closer and deeper look at the Icon Submission rules, which, among else, state this: An icon has to be at least 75% freehanded. By that, is not included screenshots and copy paste.

Also, recolours of an icon are only approvable if they show extreme usefulness. Take a look at some of my recent icon uploads - if you have a good variation, put it within the icon, not reupload it.

Hope you'll give us another shot at drawing your icons
My regards.

 

[Renly Baratheon]

Much better. Improvements after each upgrade is more obvious.

 

[Ujimasa Hojo]

Much better. Improvements after each upgrade is more obvious.

This. I like this set of yours. Very useful for weapon upgrades of Lost Ones.

 

[Shadow Fury]

They are actually better than the old ones. These icons could be useful.