BTNLandscape

[Moderator]

14:18, 19th Jun 2013
enjoy: All your work has this weird shading that makes it look like a picture with that photoshop filter that makes thing 3D, where it makes the dark points low.. It is rather odd. Your work overall looks rather flat, so you should study tutorials and reference images.
Also, you need to think about how useful the icon it. Also, you need to study highlights and shading.

A great site to look for tutorials is www.deviantart.com
You can searh for tutorials there.

 

[8512590215848]

no. Vote for rejection.

 

[Mgeterno11]

Looks nice, just like a painting. However, you should add a bit more shading for the mountain and grass. Also, try to make the sky blue and shade it, too. Good luck. 5/5 to encourage you.

 

[KaplanHorus]

everything looks like plastic toys

 

[Licheus]

Because there are not many other icons in this particular hand-drawn style, I'd have a hard time seeing the use of this. Maybe if more icons in the same style were uploaded as a pack it'd have some value in particular situations.

I am not a fan of the attitude of simply dismissing this sort of unusual resource without further analysis.

As it stands this might simply be too off the typical WarCraft III icon style and colour palette though.

 

[SpasMaster]

It's a simple and good looking paining, but it definately does not fit Warcraft. At all.

 

[Avex]

It's a simple and good looking paining, but it definately does not fit Warcraft. At all.

I didn't categorize it as WarCraft, though. It's open for any use, there are lots of icons on here that are usable for mods and the such, this was a quick sketch that I messed around with.

Because there are not many other icons in this particular hand-drawn style, I'd have a hard time seeing the use of this. Maybe if more icons in the same style were uploaded as a pack it'd have some value in particular situations.

I am not a fan of the attitude of simply dismissing this sort of unusual resource without further analysis.

As it stands this might simply be too off the typical WarCraft III icon style and colour palette though.

Thanks for the critique, though, I'll be messing with styles as I'm out of High School

 

[Moy]

Review

Points	Explanation
- 2	It's not warcraft-ish. This is warcraft not Cartooncraft (not being bad). Improve some of your future icons with a little bit contrast.

[TD] - 1 [/TD][td] It looks like plastic with a painting on it.[/td]

[TD] + 1 [/TD][td] It is freehanded..[/td] [/tr]

[/tr]

Overall

3/5

Keep up the good work, but make sure when you post another icon, see to it on what you think of your icon if it is good or bad. So that, good comments will arrive for your icon.

*Dont be offended by this. This is just a review for your icon : ) .