Hey Jolly, I created a Rating Icons system. I want to see if it gives good results. So that I can always rate icons as I rate other icons without adding my personal likings into the rating... much.
The
SyStEMmm works like that - I give you points from 0 to 1 for each of the 10 .. things an icon can have. Then I divide the result in two and add +1 since the
SyStEMmm is quite cruel (and because every icon starts from 1. WOW)
- Idea - 1
- Positioning - 0,9
- Perspective - 0,6
- Coloring - 0,9
- Color Opposition - 0,5
- Color Gamma - 0,8
- Warcraft Style - 0,6
- Shape of Object(s) - 0,8
- Highlights and Shadows - 0,8
- Quality - 0,9
Idea - Great and unique idea, what else can I say wow
Positioning - It is well-positioned, in the center and doesn't leave much blank space cuz of the aura around it (which is good).
Perspective - Not much of a perspective, but we can't ask for perspective in a plate right?
Coloring - Amazing coloring.
Color Opposition - Well... there isn't really much color opposition. It's just blue. The whole icon. Some purple, red or something like that could add a little contrast and focus more on the plate I guess.
Color Gamma - I like how the blue moves from Dark blue to Cyan. It's good. The color Gamma (under color gamma btw I mean little difference in colors.. blue to purple, red to orange, green to yellow.. etc. It adds coolness).
Warcraft Style - Not really Warcraftish though
But your style is just different. Different but good. So that's not really a minus.. that it's not war3 stylish.
Shape of Objects - The plate has great shape and all that... not much to say here.
Highlights and Shadows - I think it needs a little bit more highlights and shadows at places but it's still good enough.
Quality - Amazing quality! A bit blurry at places yes, but still amazing.
Sum:
7,8
7,8 ÷
2 =
3,9
3,9 +
1 =
4,9
Rating by
SyStEMmm:
4,9
+
0,15 from me
=
5,05
My personal opinion: Huh.. The rating turned out exactly the same as last time.. maybe I'm doing something wrong. Hmm. Although, yes. I really think it deserves a 5/5.
Keep up the good work!