BTNKnightofBlazingSun

[San]

The transition between the helmet and the shadow is unnatural, consider smoothing them up abit, it'll look better in icon size.
I'd add some light-blue to the feathers so they won't feel lonely staying behind.
You also forgot to shade the golden line part, I thought it was some kind of mustache on first sight. Dark-orange works fine when shading gold stuff.
My rough example:

 

[Diegoit]

Well, i must say i like it as it is, anyways, San coment is true, it need to improved.
This kind of icons are very useful, keep it.

 

[Wildfire]

The transition between the helmet and the shadow is unnatural, consider smoothing them up abit, it'll look better in icon size.
I'd add some light-blue to the feathers so they won't feel lonely staying behind.
You also forgot to shade the golden line part, I thought it was some kind of mustache on first sight. Dark-orange works fine when shading gold stuff.
My rough example:
View attachment 293744

Appreciate for the feedback.
Some changes:

>>>

Big image

Previous:

New:

 

[Panda]

I kinda don't understand that blue leaf on the top of the helmet, i would either add more gold parts in that area or just remove it completly because i don't see the use there. Also, when you resize it down the leafs don't really look like leafs anymore, just a blue shape. It would be nice if you added ribets towards the armor, so it looks like its connected together. Like this.

 

[Wildfire]

It is make for the custom model....

add more gold parts

I don't understand this, more golden thing on helmet?

added ribets towards the armor

I believe you mean rivets?

 

[Murlocologist]

The visor should be edited, icon would benefit in overall. And by that I mean editing the dark line on his helmet. Both edges of the line lean downwards too much, instead you could make them either in horizontal line or invert the curve so the edges are placed higher from the middle part.

 

[Panda]

It is make for the custom model....
View attachment 294000


I don't understand this, more golden thing on helmet?


I believe you mean rivets?

Yes rivets. And i said instead of having the blue leafs maybe make more golden designs around those areas. Or, just remove them because i honestly dont see a point in them.

 

[Wildfire]

I don't think it is a really big problem until overall design is spoiled... just compare it....

 

[Panda]

Well yeah thats fine, the first one is fine because you can actually see its some type of feather/leaf object flowing off of it. Put some rivets in the helm area here,

After that, should get approval.

 

[Panda]

Changes made, approved

 

[Hazop / Sarven]

Icon fits perfectly! (either than it being blue instead of red/golden)

 

[Wildfire]

Icon fits perfectly! (either than it being blue instead of red/golden)

Hope you find it useful

 

[HerrDave]

Excellent work!