BTNInventoryBag

[Moderator]

I3lackDeath Rejected [tr]

Date: 2013/Mar/27 20:11:58 Reasons: Commented.​ ​ ​ Staff Contact Submission Rules

 

[SpasMaster]

The icon looks nice, however it's up to the moderators to decide rather this has enough freework in it in order to be approved with your name under it, else it will be moved to the "blizzard" user profile. =)

 

[MiniMage]

He edited the UI I was working on, added gems, slized and dieced it. Made it an icon.
I cited resources what I used to make that UI. So technically, he edited someones edit of a work existing on deviantart.

It actually wasn't blizzard that made that bag though and now, the colors are a little bit wack in my opinion.
Since there's actually not much freehand to speak of, I doubt this will get approved.

Here's a link to the thread.
http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/...new-ui-wip-mishas-request-206901/index11.html

As I've said many times before, I have no problems when people edit stuff I've scribbled together. Just make it better than mine. Not worse.

 

[bowser499]

He edited the UI I was working on, added gems, slized and dieced it. Made it an icon.
I cited resources what I used to make that UI. So technically, he edited someones edit of a work existing on deviantart.

It actually wasn't blizzard that made that bag though and now, the colors are a little bit wack in my opinion.
Since there's actually not much freehand to speak of, I doubt this will get approved.

Here's a link to the thread.
http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/...new-ui-wip-mishas-request-206901/index11.html

Envy never makes people good, for your information.

 

[MiniMage]

Envy never makes people good, for your information.

This is not envy. This is sadness and fear.
Although to be quite honest, you essentially just need to reference this.

http://fc06.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2010/216/1/0/Game_Interface_by_cseec.png
I don't really see yours as a great improvement though.

 

[Cakedog345]

Sorry, not offence, but it's funny!
Would you imagine a fierce wc3 hero, being in situation(forced) to carry a bag like that?
Would say to himself:<Damn, i feel like Barbie now, with this "bag"! It's embarrassing!>

 

[Sin'dorei300]

lolz, you've put too much jewerly on it!

 

[bhusta]

Don't force your work to be liked bowser. You have to live with the critic.
Your work is nice as an icon but you still have to add credits.
It is not a privilege for the map section

Edit: funny thing about this icon is, that it is an edit of an edit of an edit of an edit

 

[bowser499]

bhusta,
I accept a good critique, but not pure faultfinding.

 

[I3lackDeath]

Has it ever crossed your mind that editing another artist's work and uploading the result for public use (--> distributing it) is prohibited?

MiniMage's use of it is already highly dubious, because he does not have/has shown permission to use such content, yet he hasn't uploaded anything directly usable to the public.

Kindly read our Icon Submission Rules --> Art Theft,
plus Copyright law.