BTNHammerStrike

[Moderator]

10:53, 27th Jun 2009
zombie2279: The concept is rather simple and quite similar to another one seen before. The hammer's head blends in too much with the background and the effect around it, making the whole thing look blurry. The runes in the middle seem to be okay, but the shading around and on it is almost totally missing. The effect at the lower part is rather random, seems like lines randomly drawn over the icon's parts, and therefore it's all lacking. The handle seems to be quite okay-ish, but it's not exactly woodern-like.

I recommend zooming in on the hammer's head and reworking the whole thing, as it really requires improvements and a larger area to work on means a better room for more details.

Rejected until updated.

 

[Panda]

Dont see the concept of this icon, *is the hammer smashing into the right side of the icon?* if so then add sparks coming from the front of the hammer then have the sparks come back from it. For example, http://www.wordfoundry.co.uk/trialsite/images/hammer_sparks.jpg Something like this but minus the hammer part on the picture.
(Question)
What is all the blue stuff around the handle?

 

[a7xpwns3]

HEY! YOU STOLE THE CONCEPT OF MY MAGIC HAMMER!

*cough cough MINDTHIEF! cough*

 

[lieutang]

Is it better?

 

[Justify]

HEY! YOU STOLE THE CONCEPT OF MY MAGIC HAMMER!

*cough cough MINDTHIEF! cough*

Like you've never seen a magic hammer before. Stormbolt anyone?
Blue just works best for magical runes...

I don't like the new version at all, I'd stay with the old style.

 

[a7xpwns3]

No, the handle is almost the exact same, the runes are almost the exact same - Compare my "BTNMagicHammer" and this icon. I'm not saying he stole anything other than the idea

 

[Zombie]

It is indeed rather similar, and wouldn't say it's of much better quality.