BTNGlaive

[Moderator]

16:33, 1st Dec 2009
enjoy: Define it more, and make the background less bright. It takes focus away from the weapon.

enjoy: Do as suggested.

enjoy: You haven't done as I said.. the background is still to bright, and it is still not defined enough, and now the shape is completly off.

 

[gengar]

It's good that you used CRAZYRUSSIAN's tutorial (he is best ), but that icon looks like the one he shows as example in that tutorial...
somebody could need something like shadow glaive This is exactly icon for that...
0/5 Idea
4/5 Colors
4/5 Usability
5/5 Quality
3/5 Total

I think that you need is an good idea, when you find it, you can make avesome icon!

EDIT: I changed my decision after looking at icon one more time 4/5

 

[tee.dubs]

there's nothing wrong with the idea, the background is just wack though. i had to look at it a few times before i could even see that it was a glaive of some sort, its way too bright and psychedelic to be coherent enough to see.

 

[kola]

Lol!!! this is so copied on CR.

 

[Soul Theft]

i like this one

 

[MultiGod]

Yes, I agree that there's no creativity in it(it was CR's idea), but it's kinda nice.
3.75/5