BTNDoubleSword

[Moderator]

21:49, 29th Dec 2015
Sin'dorei300: This icon doesn't feature enough quality to be approved.

 

[Roland]

Gotta "love" simple pixel magic.

 

[Golden-Drake]

Shading could be better
Lacks highligst around the blade pats to make it look sharp.
The magic part is a single line created with only a brush, it could be glowing or soemthing else.
the glow from the blades are not very bright (hard to see)
you lack a background
the hand protecter looks thin like its gonna break.

alt of things could be worked on - what program are you using to make icons?

 

[Leif]

Shading could be better
Lacks highligst around the blade pats to make it look sharp.
The magic part is a single line created with only a brush, it could be glowing or soemthing else.
the glow from the blades are not very bright (hard to see)
you lack a background
the hand protecter looks thin like its gonna break.

alt of things could be worked on - what program are you using to make icons?

Photoshop CS6

 

[Golden-Drake]

Photoshop CS6

Try to look up some tutorials about icons and try to learn from them insted of painting over or stealing (as some people have me belived).
alot of the tutorials is done in photoshop so feel free Tutorials

 

[Sin'dorei300]

It needs better definition, color variation, shading... A more accurate work will be much appreciated.
I advise u to read some tutorials:
How to Make an Icon
General Icon Process Tutorial
Basic Icons Tutorial
ICONS by Crazyrussian
Basic Icon Guide