BTNdonut

[Moderator]

17:32, 17th Jun 2009
zombie2279: First of all, you will have to put some more emphasis on the contrast and make the shape more accurate. It looks like a cake now, which is not good. Try to distinguish the outlines from the background. The shadings and highlights will also require some more work, and don't forget to use more details on it. I'd personally prefer the background removed, as it's quite distracting and it cannot be used too well as an item this way.

A sidenote: Do NOT delete and re-upload the same resource again. Use the update function instead.

8:58, 21th Jun 2009
zombie2279: Rejected until updated.

8:50, 15th Jul 2009
zombie2279: Really simple and generic, but you brought the most out of it.

 

[The Panda]

Very nicely made i love donuts lol 5/5

 

[Walle]

thx

 

[OnkelManfred]

nice new version, but a bit blurry; try to sharpen it a bit and make it clearly visible. and you may change the background to something else like a glow effect on a black color or something. but better than the first one.

offtopic: we need a model for that

 

[Avex]

...so hungry now.

Damn you! 4/5 for quality.

 

[Trillium]

mmm... tasty... 5/5... *runs to the kitchen to grab a donut*

 

[Dentothor]

well this does look tasty but as zombie said, the backround ruins it. fix it up and round out the bottom of the donut and itll be so much better

 

[Slaydon]

Black background and glow

 

[AIagremm]

Frostmourne is a thing of the past. Donut is a thing of the future!

 

[Walle]

did new background now! thx

 

[AIagremm]

Yeah, that looks much better.
Now I can rate it. 5/5

 

[OnkelManfred]

MAYBE you can round off some of the edges, but i rate it 5/5 now

 

[Zombie]

Needs further details and shading.

 

[Reaper2008]

Good job (munches donut ^^) 5/5!

 

[Haistrah]

I love <3

"Oh! a donut !" says Homer.

GG!

 

[The_Grapist]

This is great...
Can i eat it?
Nice icon btw

Rating:5/5

 

[Jack_Sparrow93]

Good idea, well done!

 

[Godslayer]

man i want more icons like that!
i would appriciate a chocolatedonut, or half eaten donut

 

[breebree123]

ohh. .very useful for an item
5/5

 

[Walle]

man i want more icons like that!
i would appriciate a chocolatedonut, or half eaten donut

nice idea!! +rep

ill make one

 

[NomarX]

This is sweet! Literally! 5/5!

 

[diehard480]

OMG I <3 DONUTS!!!! SDGJSLDGJFDJGVLDFJGDLKJGLK:FDJGF
Its a good icon but i honestly dont know what type of game to put it in :/

 

[Rufus]

Yum!