BTNDarkRangerMirrorImage

[Moderator]

02:57, 14th May 2011
Pyramidhe@d: Commented.

 

[8512590215848]

screenshot, far from creative, look's bad. Sorryz.

 

[Marsal]

Easy one but useful. I think.

 

[Marcos DAB]

Maybe useful, but I can't see any freehand...

 

[Skipper]

CnP, and small edit, Reject

 

[-Berz-]

Well its obvious what you did there... but I guess mods could make an exception on this and approve this due to its uses, not every map maker has the skill and time to make such icon. So from my point of view this should get approved. Anyway it's up to mods and not me.

 

[yurneric]

screenshot, far from creative, look's bad. Sorryz.

It wasn't a screenshot. You can compare it to the original icon (pixel to pixel). I just took the original icon, shaded it, shifted it leftwards, and repeat the process for a second time. And then, voila.. Done.

My purpose is to make useful icons that saves up people's time. It's still up to mods to decide. Quality wise, I suppose I could say it's the same as the original hero icon.

 

[Jake Command Wolf]

Honestly all trolling and bashing aside, it's simple but nice. Someone will find use for it and that's grounds for a 3-star approval to me.

Regards,

Jake

P.S. - Some + rep for you, since your new, yet this is rather well done.

 

[InfernalTater]

This is too simple of an edit. I've submitted plenty of works that looked better and were more original that were rejected for not quite being original enough. Yurneric will probably have to put his more simple resources into a seperate thread for other people to use, without officially uploading them, until he starts to make things from scratch. CnP isn't allowed, and neither are simple hue/saturation/brightness changes, unless, of course, they are changes to something you drew yourself. Icons have to be 100% freehand, and skins need to be at least around 60% freehand or so, it appears.

 

[Maximum_Evil]

could be useful

 

[The Panda]

If you was looking for this type of image use it for yourself instead of uploading it here, the hive doesn't need a CnP of the same image 3 times. :/

 

[yurneric]

If you was (grammar error) looking for this type of image use it for yourself instead of uploading it here, the hive doesn't need a CnP of the same image 3 times. :/

Of course the hive doesn't need it. But the map makers do.

I'm just uploading it as a necessary proof that what I use in my map is not from unknown/buggy resource.

 

[InfernalTater]

We don't need you to prove to us what you use in your own map. If you upload something it's supposed to be something that we could use. Something that saves us more than 30 seconds of time and no talent to recreate.

 

[yurneric]

Something that saves us more than 30 seconds of time and no talent to recreate.

(sarcasm)Oh, I would love to see you make it in less than 30 seconds.(/sarcasm)

 

[chr2]

Okay, seriously. Do not except to get anything but negative feedback when uploading an icon like this. Though, I must admit it is pretty well done, it's still something anyone with GIMP or photoshop could make in a couple of minutes. Freehand and reupload it, and it should be ready for approval, cause this is indeed a needed icon.

 

[yurneric]

In my opinion (no offence), the usefulness of an icon and its "freehand-ness" is TWO TOTALLY DIFFERENT thing.

I know the importance of having originality in terms of freehand drawing, BUT what difference is there if I were to draw the same Dark Ranger face from another angle and remake the icon the same way as I did?

To put it simply, I don't see any increase in terms of usefulness from

to

. Probably just the eyes are obviously of different color.

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

ok. here is the thing. i approve this then it gives me no reason to not accept an exact same icon as this with darkranger replaced with a kodo or a blademaster or grunt or whatever.

ie. i want you to draw your own stuff

 

[InfernalTater]

yurneric, the issue is, if every 2-minute icon was accepted for usefulness, then we would be unable to sort through such icons to find actual freehanded icons.
Usefulness is not just whether or not something will be used, it's whether or not something is difficult to make.
For example, everyone needs water, but it's easier to obtain than diamond which really has no use. Therefore, diamond is worth more, even though nobody really needs it.

 

[yurneric]

Understood. Don't worry.