BTNdagger

[Moderator]

14:38, 25th Sep 2009
Zombie.: Rather simple, not particularly creative and lacks proper details. I'd imagine it rather hard to fix. Try doing some proper contrast on the handle, a color scheme usage unrelated to the background, some more contrast, highlights and a lighter gray, metal-like scheme on the blade. Altogether, fix the shading and highlights, do something with the messy, random and low-quality background and don't forget to fix the DISBTN.

Rejected until updated.

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Looks good, i think.

 

[Dentothor]

This lacks a whole ton of detail to be approved at all. youve got the right idea for shading, but the shape, detail and BGs are what you really need to work on.

 

[Panda]

I don't like the background at all, but once again i suggest making either a glow or mist around the sword. And, also the shading seems too dark. You may wanna make the part that is suppose to be lighter a bit more lighter as it is a little dark at the moment. Also, the darkest part needs to be just a tad-bit less dark since its suppose to be a shadow instead of a main color or an object.

 

[Dj0z]

I don't like it tbh.

 

[Deuterium]

Needs more details, fixing, and different background