BTNBlueShaman

[Moderator]

16:10, 19th Oct 2014
Sin'dorei300: It's way too close to the original, there's no need to make an icon identical with one that already exists.
Also, its quality isn't better than the original.
Try to make somethin' different.

 

[Razosh]

Looks somewhat to familiar.

It isn't a complete copy-pasted version of the original but I have a very hard time seeing the use for this one as the only actual difference is the lip color. Yours really can't be used anywhere that the original can't. It's definitely not bad work don't get me wrong, it just seems useless.

 

[stonneash]

Looks somewhat to familiar.

It isn't a complete copy-pasted version of the original but I have a very hard time seeing the use for this one as the only actual difference is the lip color. Yours really can't be used anywhere that the original can't. It's definitely not bad work don't get me wrong, it just seems useless.

The icon you have is just a recolor of the original Warcraft III shaman icon (I believe). My icon is completely from scratch except that i used the original to trace some of the outlines and as a reference.
PSD file attached as proof.

 

[Razosh]

As I said not a complete copy paste, the point was I do not see why anyone would use it instead of the original.

 

[A Void]

As I said not a complete copy paste, the point was I do not see why anyone would use it instead of the original.

Your point contradicts to a lot of icons in icon section. That means that 70% of icons in Hive are useless.... #yourlogic isamazing.

 

[Razosh]

Your point contradicts to a lot of icons in icon section. That means that 70% of icons in Hive are useless.... #yourlogic isamazing.

What icons are you looking at? The vast majority of icons are vastly different than any made by Blizzard.

 

[Forsaken]

Looks good! xD