BTNBanana

[Moderator]

19:23, 28th Apr 2009
Paladon: Changes made, differences are definitely noticeable, i recommend this icon.

 

[Zombie]

Well, it could be useful. You really need to make a difference between the fruit and its skin by sharpening (or adding) outlines, and making them in different colors. The shading also appears to be totally missing, though I see some lightning effects on it, but those aren't enough to make a difference.

What I don't understand is: Why did you upload it if you know it's not ready yet?

 

[expazatrix]

Very bright in yellow.
This is a useful Icon but low quality.
For me its 3/5.

 

[FrIkY]

Needs more shading and hue it to more orange color. You could also give it some light glow.

 

[Thorneon]

alright, maybe i will attempt to work on it.

 

[Paladon]

Just more shading ("depth"^^), it's your personal problem right now.
Your icons appear a bit too 2D~ish all the time.
Improve that, and they are very nice.

 

[lieutang]

more shading ... ye

 

[a7xpwns3]

Maybe a little darker? It's a little hard to make out details in this brightness.
At first it looked like an MSPaint banana (Shocking, I know, right?) but then I looked closer and found greater detail.
Darker, more shading.
No more comments.

 

[Thorneon]

is there anyone who can help me out with shading cause that seems to be my problem

 

[a7xpwns3]

I could... >_<
I can shade geometrical figures... I'll post an imageshack image of what I'm thinking of.

EDIT:
Merry Christmahanakwanzica.

 

[Misha]

make the fleshy part of the banana white-ish and add moar shading 'n' highlights.

~Misha~

 

[Thorneon]

oh yeah forot to update

 

[a7xpwns3]

Still, needs to be darker, and more shading on the bottom-left triangular portion of the banana (Look at my version and you'll see the shading)

 

[Paladon]

I agree, especially in the marked area. The banana blends too much with the skin otherwise.
If you have improved that, i am going to approve this very useful banana.

 

[Thorneon]

alright, im on the wrong comp right now but ill get it fixed either later today or tomorrow


Updated! (hopefully final DD)

 

[Paladon]

...very nice.

 

[GooS]

Tel'Abim Banana, looks better than the WoW one

Indeed additional food icons could be useful for RPG maps.

I'd give it a 4/5 since there are some color faults and some spots lack in detail.

 

[expazatrix]

Looks heaps better now!
It could go with that Banana model I saw earlier....
5/5 it deserves.

 

[Thorneon]

Yay! thanks for all the great comments guys! Im really glad you all like it! DD

 

[a7xpwns3]

I rate... 24 x 7 + 72 / 2 x 7 x 2 - 1337 / 3 - 64.33333333333333333333333333333333 / 10 out of 5

(5/5)

 

[Remend]

this is a quite good icon but where are we going to use it?
4/5

 

[Mamma_Pappa]

Bananaphone.

 

[S.W.I.N.E]

unuseful to me, but awesome icon

 

[GreySkull]

Beautiful background.