BTNAdg

[Moderator]

10:37, 31st Dec 2010
Pyramidhe@d: This icon, truth be told, is terrible. No shading, no higlights, the shape is uneven.

 

[13L4M3]

What the heck is that :O?

 

[maxor_gan]

What is this???
I suppose the "Description" column there got has some purpose. =\

 

[Krl70]

No shading, strange white lines, and very strange shape.

rating: N/A, voting for rejection.

 

[Hugomath]

Its a dagger (by " adg " he probably meant "Adaga"[Portuguese]).

Anyway, what the hell? It an knife going through wind or something. Besides, the shape makes it look like a mini scimitar. lol

 

[maxor_gan]

I knew what it is...A Protoss' Umbrella! =3

 

[Blood Raven]

Well, there is no shading and these white lines (supposed to be something like swing) are awful... but a good start for iconmaking... You could read some 2D art Tutorials. the Best i know is NFWar's Icon making Tutorial (add rep when you read it)
I hope you'll learn something from there...