Blade of the Frost Warrior

[Panda]

Looks pretty neat, Maybe zoom in a bit more. Also, for the blade itself, at the bottom area make a small shine like you did on the top part to make it seem more transparent.

 

[stonneash]

Spoiler: Review

Grade: 6/10 D

Spoiler: More

Definition: The Ability of an Icon to be indistinguishable from the other icons in Warcraft III.
Note: The Icon doesn't stick out too much and fits decently, but a good way to make this better is to add some black outlines.

Grade: 8/10 B

Spoiler: More

Definition: The Ability of an Icon to be serve a purpose of high demand and low supply, or multiple low demand instances.
Note: The Icon features a few of the borders along with the subject being a sword opening an avenue to a large amount of potential implementations.

Grade: 7/10 C

Spoiler: More

Note: Use some of blizzards icons as a reference to your target for a better fit unless you are trying to keep your own take on the style and feel of things, also include all of the borders. We have the button manager tool which makes this process super easy.

Grade: 7/10 C

Spoiler: More

Definition: The scale of how well the Artist has utilized perspective to add depth and definition.
Note: Classic 2D flat display. good for showing details, but not very creative or unique.

Grade: 7/10 C

Spoiler: More

Definition: The scale of how well the Artist has utilized colors, shadings, outlines, and other tools to best present the subject.
Note: Wonderful job with the colors and shading, they match very well, but you have not utilized outlines to better define the subject, also the shading can be a little stronger for a metallic effect.

Grade: 7/10 C

Spoiler: More

Note: Looks decent. Nice work

Spoiler: Stonneash's Note

Nice work! Hope to see more of your work soon.

C

Edit: Background is cool and unique, but I'm not sure if its superior to the classic way of blizzard so I committed mentioning it.

 

[San]

The handle should be darker than the blade in my opinion.
Rough example:

 

[8512590215848]

Separate a background from the sword's edge please Apart from that - really eye candy style.

 

[plazma019]

The handle should be darker than the blade in my opinion.
Rough example:
View attachment 283080

There is a light on the bottom of cross-guard

 

[Darkfang]

this is really nice!

 

[nedio95]

Is it me or is everything in the icon very sharp?
It looks to me that every part is separated, blade, guard, handle, background.
Looks good, don't get me wrong, but it looks... well, a bit wrong. Reminds me of a bad CGI... Like a 3D model...

-Ned