Arcadian Forest

[Moderator]

Moderator: -Kobas-
Contact: Visitor Message / Private Message!
Date: 16-Jul-13 (19:07:05)​

Critical Errors:​

Your Map has low quality terrain.

Useful Links:​

The Important Site Rules.
You can use Map Development Section for testing and improving your maps.
Got any World Editor related questions? Make a thread in the World Editor Help Zone Section
The Important Site Tutorials.
If you have any complaints or questions about your map, please make a thread here: Map Resource Moderation.

Personal Comment:​

Read melee map tutorials.
You have made a lot of newbie mistakes.

Map Status: Rejected
(1/5) Unacceptable​

 

[WolfFarkas]

[Reviewer template made by Legal_Ease]

abgm's review ***Arcadian Forest*** Map Overview ***For a 4 player melee map, a lot of work is needed to improve*** What I liked: *** -Starting locations, placed as square *** What could be improved: *** 1)all neutral buildings placed in a same place. 2) creeps doesnt loot items 3) wild terrain all flat 4) 100% one tile set the grass 5) the form of the map is not very atractive to me, i saw maps like this and in my opinion log and log and log, i think it can be better 6) not a single doodad, so the enviroment is missing *** Rating and Final Thoughts: ***rejection*** ***No, good enviroment, no good terrain, game play isnt that good because the loot system and neutral buildings in a same place,so in the end there arent good things, also you can make this map in 30-60 mins, the only effort here is to put trees,*** i sugest you to read tutorials, study approved maps, or blizzard maps to improve screen of the map Uploaded with ImageShack.us

 

[Arcadia]

[Reviewer template made by Legal_Ease]

abgm's review ***Arcadian Forest*** Map Overview ***For a 4 player melee map, a lot of work is needed to improve*** What I liked: *** -Starting locations, placed as square *** What could be improved: *** 1)all neutral buildings placed in a same place. 2) creeps doesnt loot items 3) wild terrain all flat 4) 100% one tile set the grass 5) the form of the map is not very atractive to me, i saw maps like this and in my opinion log and log and log, i think it can be better 6) not a single doodad, so the enviroment is missing *** Rating and Final Thoughts: ***rejection*** ***No, good enviroment, no good terrain, game play isnt that good because the loot system and neutral buildings in a same place,so in the end there arent good things, also you can make this map in 30-60 mins, the only effort here is to put trees,*** i sugest you to read tutorials, study approved maps, or blizzard maps to improve screen of the map Uploaded with ImageShack.us

I updated terrain, doodads, mobs, etc. The map was redone to fix the issues you mentioned. There's a spread terrain, mobs drop loot now, the shops are spread, I lowered the number of tree walls, the terrain has several rocks and many wild plants, there are barrels located near each shop, and there are random rolling hills, along with a large hill at the location of the Red Dragon Roost in the center.