Amber Garden

[Moderator]

14:05, 16th Jan 2011
-Kobas-:
Map Status: Approved
Broken Rules:
/
Comment

 

[light bolt30]

Vote for rejection:
-Author name different to upload
-Bad description
-Judging from author name, this map has been stolen therefore no effort has been put into this map.
Also add category next time when you upload.
RATING: N/A REJECTION

 

[Darkzealot_128]

Why bother posting a blizzard map? We probably already have one in our warcraft 3 map folder.

 

[Adiktuz]

I'm getting the feeling that this is a default melee map made by Blizzard... and oh, its a new user, 0 posts...

 

[Ironside]

Aww, a normal melee map. Well I guess we can't do much here since everyone has this map in his maps folder....

 

[Adiktuz]

I'd vote for 5/5 but to Blizzard not you...

 

[Ironside]

Indeed, all the Blizzard Melee would probably be approved here, but since it's not yours and everyone already has it in the map folder

 

[Pourquoi]

Vote for REJECTION. (Blatant) stolen map and bad description.

 

[yuvixadun]

Hahaha, well it isn't stolen and it isn't a blizzard map. I made this map myself some years ago and just uploaded it for the fun of it. I am the author (drol) and I'm active on "thehelper forum" as that name. (link to my profile there: http://www.thehelper.net/forums/member.php?u=27882)

Im sorry for the short description, but what can I type when its just a plain melee map?

PS
I find it quite offensive to instantly think I stole a map just because an account name is different.

 

[WindowsVistaSucks]

I knew it!
Besides... Even if it was made by BlizzardEntertainment, this would not be rejected.

 

[Adiktuz]

I thought it was because it said made by Blizzard Entertainment before but now it says drol... ^^

 

[-Peper-]

Edited, maybe?

 

[yuvixadun]

Edited, maybe?

True, I updated it, apparently I typed Blizzard Entertainment somewhere for fun. Fixed now so no people reply on that matter

 

[66Dragon6]

Man its like Melee Maps bring out the worse in people around here....

hurr durr I need a 100 page description for a map with no imports , no triggers, and no special events that takes less than 30 seconds to view and play.

 

[Adiktuz]

Man its like Melee Maps bring out the worse in people around here....

hurr durr I need a 100 page description for a map with no imports , no triggers, and no special events that takes less than 30 seconds to view and play.

whatttt?????????

 

[yuvixadun]

I don't trust you still. Also, you typed Blizzard Entertainment for fun? I don't believe you because I think that would be pointless and unfunny to do. And you forgot to 'fix' it?

Edit: I checked the map and everything seems too perfect, and it also seems Blizzardy. Most good mellee maps have a good description,

So 'drol'. I would like more evidence please.

How do you want me to prove such a thing? I don't really care you're so frustrated over this. I did make the map, if you think its a blizzard map, just scroll to your default maps and notice it isnt there.

And thanks for saying its perfect

Now please; I would like constructive feedback on the map, any suggestions?

 

[Ironside]

Oh, I apologize for not noticing it's not a default map...

But you still need to improve the description, so say the rules.

 

[Adiktuz]

maybe some more elements... another normal melee map isnt really needed... or at least improve the description, say something about the terrain maybe or expand the background story like those normal melee maps...

 

[yuvixadun]

I've gave a bigger description, but its hard to say anything that isnt shortlisted yet in the standard map information. Melee maps just aren't so descriptive as custom ones I guess

I know it isn't in my default maps, I just want a teensy bit more proof and we will forget this ever happened and i'll give you an apology. I'm, still suspicious about how it said 'created by Blizzard Entertainment'.

I think I did it at that time because I wanted to try and create a blizzard like melee map, so adding them as author made it more blizzard-like. It gives a blueish icon when you scroll through the maplist.

 

[Adiktuz]

maybe you could add some in-game screenies... ^^

 

[yuvixadun]

maybe you could add some in-game screenies... ^^

Great idea, Ill do that

 

[Adiktuz]

 

[Lambdadelta]

PS
I find it quite offensive to instantly think I stole a map just because an account name is different.

Same But you just need to get over it, not get offended, and just post evidence to prove you are that person. I think I ought to do something like this to stir some trouble and see how fast I get comments like: 'uploader name is not author name = rejected". Bleh.

It gives a blueish icon when you scroll through the maplist.

OMFG. So having the author name as Blizzard Entertainment gave that thing? OMG. <3

 

[dead-man-walking]

Well... Melees don't need on big helluva description... Just a complete information on number of Mines and Neutral Buildings.

 

[-Kobas-]

Moderation

Amber Garden
Created by drol ; Uploaded by: yuvixadun

Review

Awesome, improve your skills a little and you will create blizzard like maps!
I have few suggestions:
Add more doodads to map center, look empty this way!
Fix trees, must stay next to each other! (Remove empty space between them)

Map status: Approved

Broken Rules:
/
Thread Cleaned:
/
Status: Approved

 

[eubz]

I don't know that maps with "default melee initialization" could be approved... No customs or anything customs at all...

 

[yuvixadun]

I don't know that maps with "default melee initialization" could be approved... No customs or anything customs at all...

Its a new melee map for those who are bored with the default Blizzard ones, the terrain and everything is new

 

[Adiktuz]

ofc it can be, especially as its type is "Melee"... if you add customs, then its already, "altered melee"...