(8)Misty Mystery V1.06

[mafe]

So I didnt find any difference between the 4 and 8 player version except for the starting positions and the differen neutral buildings?

Overall I think the map is ok as a 4 player 2v2 or FFA map, for 2v2v2v2 it might also work, but for 4v4 there isnt enough space to move 4 armies around if they are grouped up.
Notes:
1. Boats: I still believe most players wont like them, no matter how good the map is. Anyway, the way they are used here is ok.
2. The 8 player version needs shops.
3. The shops/mana fountains should not be usable during the day without killing creeps.
4. The expansions near the center don have much space, but I dont see an easy fix.
5. There are many "safe wisp" spots.
6. There no creepcamps close to the main bases. This makes for a very awkward early game.

So overall, the 4 player maps is superior atm. Its only real bug is 3, but 6 definitely is an issue too.
I think you can make some improvements (for 2, 3, and 6 at least) in a reasonable amount of time. Therefore map set to Awaiting Update.

 

[Zucth]

So I didnt find any difference between the 4 and 8 player version except for the starting positions and the differen neutral buildings?

Overall I think the map is ok as a 4 player 2v2 or FFA map, for 2v2v2v2 it might also work, but for 4v4 there isnt enough space to move 4 armies around if they are grouped up.
Notes:
1. Boats: I still believe most players wont like them, no matter how good the map is. Anyway, the way they are used here is ok.
2. The 8 player version needs shops.
3. The shops/mana fountains should not be usable during the day without killing creeps.
4. The expansions near the center don have much space, but I dont see an easy fix.
5. There are many "safe wisp" spots.
6. There no creepcamps close to the main bases. This makes for a very awkward early game.

So overall, the 4 player maps is superior atm. Its only real bug is 3, but 6 definitely is an issue too.
I think you can make some improvements (for 2, 3, and 6 at least) in a reasonable amount of time. Therefore map set to Awaiting Update.

One thing I do wonder about is the 3. [my Fountain have a guard though, how can someone use it in the day?]

 

[mafe]

Looking at the changes with respect to my previous feedback:
2. Shops are there now.
3. Fountain creeps are placed bette rnow.
4. Not 100% sure if I remember how it looked previously. Still not ideal, but I think it's improved now.
5. Still exist, but so what.
6. Still no creep close to spawns location.

I like the tileset and the basic idea for the location. The map still feels "weird" to me in some ways, but objectively it's good enough to be approved now.