Mush

[Moderator]

14:19, 16th Jan 2011
-Kobas-:
Map Status: Approved
Broken Rules:
/
Comment

 

[Darkzealot_128]

Gonna check, also, put hidden tags on those screenshots.

Edit: This is enough proof that you own the mellee map, so i'm sorry, and also, I actually quite like this map. The terrain seems good, the gameplay seems nice and fun, there is lots of information provided in the quests, I really like it how theres lots of settings, and I also like it how you can pick from a wide range of races, but could you tell me how you get gold?

And also incase your map leaks (I can't check triggering due to protection), here: http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/general-mapping-tutorials-278/complete-list-things-leak-126761/

Voting for: APPROVAL and 4/5

And +rep for making the first decent map in a while.

 

[yuvixadun]

Gonna check, also, put hidden tags on those screenshots. And it says created by drol and uploaded by yuvixadun. Please explain.

Added the tags.

I am the author (drol), yuvixadun is just another nickname. I've uploaded this map before on thehelper forum site as that name. You can check it here:
http://www.thehelper.net/forums/member.php?u=27882
and
http://world-editor-tutorials.thehelper.net/maps.php?view=1520

 

[drakexx]

Epic map tearrian can "change" with weather lol
so 5/5+apro cuz of epic fun,idea

 

[yuvixadun]

Gonna check, also, put hidden tags on those screenshots.

Edit: This is enough proof that you own the mellee map, so i'm sorry, and also, I actually quite like this map. The terrain seems good, the gameplay seems nice and fun, there is lots of information provided in the quests, I really like it how theres lots of settings, and I also like it how you can pick from a wide range of races, but could you tell me how you get gold?

And also incase your map leaks (I can't check triggering due to protection), here: http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/general-mapping-tutorials-278/complete-list-things-leak-126761/

Voting for: APPROVAL and 4/5

And +rep for making the first decent map in a while.

Thanks a lot Ill do the map leaking check.
You gain gold every 10 seconds, and the amount increases depending on how many buildings you've build, they generate your income. The mush (lumber) is gained when you spend gold on building buildings.
I think that should be stated in the quest log or when you hover over your gold.

Thanks for the feedback

 

[light bolt30]

Can't you think of a better name other than 'Mush'? Doesn't sound very appealing.

 

[Eldubs]

mush sounds good, and i am going to dl and play! Wait for a good reviw.

 

[FrozenFenrir]

Tested the map.

first the pros:
i really liked the idea of the sea line. quite unique.
i also liked the usage of custom models.

now for the cons:
it extremely appears like a castle fight rip-off.
played 2player vs 2bots
the first round was automatically chosen? wtf?
also after the first round we used pickable race, then we got a window with "choose your race" written on it but WITHOUT ANY OPTIONS TO CHOOSE FROM(<--needs definately to be fixed, otherwise it will never get an approval from me)
some units also seem very imballanced to me (small tank for example)
is it really necessary to have similiiar towers+ultimates(in case of dmg+skills) for every race...?


rating:
2/5 lacking + vote for rejection for now.
make it less like a copy of cf and make it more your own way.
the rejection is because of the pick a race bug which makes the game unplayable if this mode has been chosen.

 

[Goosebearslug]

Please change the name and change the amount of players from 1-8 to 1-10. Testing now.

 

[FrozenFenrir]

Please change the name and change the amount of players from 1-8 to 1-10. Testing now.

how about giving him actually a REASON why he should do this?
mush sounds fine to me.

 

[yuvixadun]

I'm keeping the name, sorry if some people don't like it. About the other issues (like the buttons when choosing modes after the first round) I will try to fix them and update the map in the coming days.

Thanks for the feedback

EDIT: I've uploaded a new version that doesn't bug at the menu "choose race". Will look into the other stuff later on, for now this version works 100%.

 

[Goosebearslug]

Ok, I tested the map twice with a few people online and everyone seemed to enjoy it. If you buy an item on your worker then play another round the items you brought last round will still be on the floor. Also for balancing I sudjest making the nagas building that steals an enemies unit cost more gold and lumber because I won in 1v2 by spamming them :/. Overall it is a good map but is very similar to castlefight >.> perhaps think up a few original ideas to put in the map then it will boost my rateing from 4/5 to 5/5.
Good job on the map

 

[yuvixadun]

Ok, I tested the map twice with a few people online and everyone seemed to enjoy it. If you buy an item on your worker then play another round the items you brought last round will still be on the floor. Also for balancing I sudjest making the nagas building that steals an enemies unit cost more gold and lumber because I won in 1v2 by spamming them :/. Overall it is a good map but is very similar to castlefight >.> perhaps think up a few original ideas to put in the map then it will boost my rateing from 4/5 to 5/5.
Good job on the map

Okay, thanks for your feedback Will try to work on it, will certainly fix that item bug.

 

[FrozenFenrir]

EDIT: I've uploaded a new version that doesn't bug at the menu "choose race". Will look into the other stuff later on, for now this version works 100%.

dunno what you "fixed" bit it still has no options in the current version....

 

[Goosebearslug]

Yeah I didnt think you could choose your own race either until I clicked custom mode :/. That allows you to pick from a variety of things.

 

[yuvixadun]

dunno what you "fixed" bit it still has no options in the current version....

Yeah I didnt think you could choose your own race either until I clicked custom mode :/. That allows you to pick from a variety of things.

You can pick your own settings when you chose "custom game" at the start of the map

 

[FrozenFenrir]

You can pick your own settings when you chose "custom game" at the start of the map

looks like you missunderstood me...
again. if you select the "choose your race" mode, you dont have any races to choose from, only a blank box without any content which leads to a game quit since you cant close that stupid box.

 

[yuvixadun]

looks like you missunderstood me...
again. if you select the "choose your race" mode, you dont have any races to choose from, only a blank box without any content which leads to a game quit since you cant close that stupid box.

Okay, to test this I just downloaded the file and played chosing custom game. Everything works fine for me. Perhaps you're still using an old version where that bug exists?

I'm sorry for it, it should be fixed in the newest version.

 

[Yondo]

Nice map! I liked it, I would suggest you add more abilities to the uber units!!!!

 

[-Kobas-]

Moderation

Mush
Created by drol ; Uploaded by: yuvixadun

Review

Gameplay look very nice, tooltips are ok, units and models very nice!
Still I don't like terrain!
Location leaks looks cleaned...

Map quality is above acceptable...

Map status: Approved
Good job dude!

Broken Rules:
/
Thread Cleaned:
/
Status: Approved

 

[lurebr]

Hi, I just tried the map, it's pretty much like castle fight xD I loved it. Here the issues I found:

1 - Once, playing with a friend of mine, he used rescue but the score didn't change.
2 - He bought 3 blast satff, and when we remake the game, the itens were near the castle. He picked it up and couldn't drop anymore. boring bug
3 - When we remake a 2x2 game and try to remake as custom game, it stuck, i can't choose any custom options.

 

[yuvixadun]

Hi, I just tried the map, it's pretty much like castle fight xD I loved it. Here the issues I found:

1 - Once, playing with a friend of mine, he used rescue but the score didn't change.
2 - He bought 3 blast satff, and when we remake the game, the itens were near the castle. He picked it up and couldn't drop anymore. boring bug
3 - When we remake a 2x2 game and try to remake as custom game, it stuck, i can't choose any custom options.

Should be solved in the new version
Thanks for reporting!

 

[Magnet199]

very nice map
its like castle fight that lasts longer (which its bad for me, because my pc laggs lol)
good job keep it up

 

[yuvixadun]

very nice map
its like castle fight that lasts longer (which its bad for me, because my pc laggs lol)
good job keep it up

Thank you
I did change some triggers to make it less heavy for the machine, but the rather large map size and the amount of units does cause lag unfortunately (especially late game). Any suggestions to reduce that are more than welcome

 

[SA Dashie]

The problem is most likely leaks from unreamoved locations/player groups ect.If you dont know about how to fix leaks yet this totorial will teach you how to fix leaks and a bit extra!

 

[yuvixadun]

The problem is most likely leaks from unreamoved locations/player groups ect.If you dont know about how to fix leaks yet this totorial will teach you how to fix leaks and a bit extra!

Thanks for the help, but I do remove location and group leaks, I even destroy map init triggers after execution. Think it's the number of units late game.

 

[Magnet199]

yep its the late units lol
again DONT STOP WORKING ON IT, looking forward to play more of this game
because castle fight stop updating

 

[yuvixadun]

yep its the late units lol
again DONT STOP WORKING ON IT, looking forward to play more of this game
because castle fight stop updating

Yeah, the lack of updates of Castle Fight is rather disappointing. I'll try to keep this map as updated as possible.

All feedback is still welcome

 

[sentrywiz]

I am a Castle Fight fanatic so I'll definately try this map and tell you that it looks like a total rip-off. Gex wouldn't be happy with you

Other than that, I like how it looks.
I also like that there is naval now.

Ability descriptions are definately like ones in CF. Map overlay is like CF. Basically you wanted to make your own CF?

 

[yuvixadun]

I am a Castle Fight fanatic so I'll definately try this map and tell you that it looks like a total rip-off. Gex wouldn't be happy with you

Other than that, I like how it looks.
I also like that there is naval now.

Ability descriptions are definately like ones in CF. Map overlay is like CF. Basically you wanted to make your own CF?

Yes, CF with a twist. CF wasn't the first of its type of map, there was battlefield before that if I remember correctly.

Hope you have some fun with this map

 

[Magnet199]

UPDATES PLEASE
i want MORE OF THIS !!!!!!!!
Please? (^^)

 

[yuvixadun]

UPDATES PLEASE
i want MORE OF THIS !!!!!!!!
Please? (^^)

Glad you enjoy it so much
What do you have in mind for updates?

I'm currently working on my TD map, but if I have some spare time I'll try to realize some of your idea's.

 

[Magnet199]

hm hm hm, ideas
ok here you go

- first of all choice for race or random (modes like castle fight )
- more epic races
- HOW TO CLOSE WEATHER (my pc sucks -_-)
- units for each race
- how about that gold thingy that increases income like in castle fight, or no? like dont make the builder to build, becuase its full slot, although you could put two build options you know map can non-stop improving with units, i can feel it 3-5 versions more the map will be epic enough for everyone to know it :O
please just add anything please please please

 

[yuvixadun]

hm hm hm, ideas
ok here you go

- first of all choice for race or random (modes like castle fight )

You can pick a race by chosing "Custom Game" at the start of a game, here you can set your own game.

- more epic races

Got a lot of races already, I think I'll focus on balancing those out first

- HOW TO CLOSE WEATHER (my pc sucks -_-)

You can turn it off at game settings in the "Custom Game" option at the start of a game

- units for each race

How you mean? New units? That will be pretty hard to make due to interface limits.

- how about that gold thingy that increases income like in castle fight, or no? like dont make the builder to build, becuase its full slot, although you could put two build options you know map can non-stop improving with units, i can feel it 3-5 versions more the map will be epic enough for everyone to know it :O
please just add anything please please please

Glad you like it so much, I'll see what I can do. Its just not my priority yet, but I'll do my best to finish my current project and focus back on this

 

[Magnet199]

Yeah sure take your time
again your maps look nice i will give ya feedback on them also (soon)

 

[Shubac]

me and my brother liked this game but i got pissed off when his batrider rushed my darkness towers when he got debuffed

 

[yuvixadun]

For those who like this map; I've made an improved CF like map: Black Law Hills

http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/maps-564/black-law-hills-1-7-1-a-206429/

 

[deepstrasz]

Restarting the game may end up with an Undead AI that does not play.
Bear Riders stop at the middle of the lower lane.
Artillery towers are overpowered.
Life Gate is overpowered. There should be a limit of how many could be built.
There's a bug with the text wrongly saying how many units were killed by the large explosion.
There's also a problem with troops doing what the players put them to, sometimes.

Maybe a lil more work on balance.
Add skip cinematic for faster play.

I played this map a lot of times. It's fun but also frustrating due to some imbalanced stuff. For some reason I like it more than Black Law Hills.

 

[deepstrasz]

Are workers supposed to repair mechanical units? They just go after them instead of repairing the buildings. Gotta' be extra careful.
The undead AI built two giants and that should not be allowed.

 

[cleavinghammer]

If artillery is voted off, it shouldn't be for sale.
Buildings should have a suicide command.

There should be a sea and land two-lane mode.
Why is income capped at 80?
There should be a vote to allow/disallow legendary units.