Swamps Of Sorrow v1.0

Moderator · Dec 28, 2010

08:31, 28th Jun 2011
-Kobas-:
Status: Rejected
Comment

Eldubs · Dec 28, 2010

Look pretty nice, also, the third picture is the same as the first.

light bolt30 · Dec 29, 2010

A better way of taking the screenshot is to show the entire terrain. Judging from the screenshots, the terrain is poorly made due to the fact everything is flat which is really plain. The placement of goldmines of having three goldmines at your starting positions IMO just discourages people to explore and find new goldmines to build bases and really just uses up a lot of the space in the base. Please add a category and a map type.

drakexx · Dec 29, 2010

heh i forgot to put some things cuz i completed it at 3:00 A.m. time xD

The Olympus king · Dec 29, 2010

Is there some new races or warriors?

Eldubs · Dec 29, 2010

Its a normal melee map

ap0calypse · Dec 29, 2010

Eldubs said:
Its a normal melee map

It says "Altered Melee" (type).

I'd better check this out :/

Okay, it's a normal melee map (change the type, please).
The drops aren't random enough (you must find a balance between static and too random).
The terrain is very geometrically built and the raise/lower-tool hasn't been used.
The only purpose of the cliffs is to divide the lands, but this has been done with a very unnatural feeling.

Aside from aesthetics, the map is very balanced and great for 2v2v2v2, with a lot of resources and additional mines to defend.
A downside is that there is no green camp, the drop (as said before) are not random and the terrain could greatly be improved.

drakexx · Dec 29, 2010

It's Altered Melee

Check description, "Lumber in this map is Unlimited"

And i will improve it,thx for review.

ap0calypse · Dec 29, 2010

I read the entire description and still missed that (and I also checked the objects and missed it?)
I kinda failed D:

Oh well, the no-lumber thing fits with the amount of gold resources which are available so that wouldn't be a reason for rejecting it.
Thanks for clarifying that

Eldubs · Dec 29, 2010

It would be apriciated to use better quality pictures in your description. (it really kinda hurts my eyes) You can use other picture formats aside JPG. Altho most of my pictures are JPG, but for some reason they look better. No offence i like the map and all but the pictures just keeps getting into my eyes, Also removing or recoloring the white area could be great! For example you could use the color used in THW as background.

5/5

drakexx · Dec 30, 2010

Improved the quality of 1st picture,it's better now

Thank you for rate

The Olympus king said:
Is there some new races or warriors?

no

Eldubs · Dec 30, 2010

Merge your posts into one post.

The Olympus king · Jan 4, 2011

drakexx said:
improved the quality of 1st picture,it's better now

thank you for rate

no

bah!

Eldubs · Jan 4, 2011

The Olympus king said:
bah!

Dude, you better lay down. This counts as an insult.

ap0calypse · Jan 4, 2011

Eldubs said:
Dude, you better lay down. This counts as an insult.

Whaaa? Since when? How?

Eldubs · Jan 4, 2011

If olympus is a muslim bah is a curseword.

ap0calypse · Jan 4, 2011

Eldubs said:
If olympus is a muslim bah is a curseword.

I'm quite sure you confuse 'muslim' with [country], as not all muslims speak the same language.
"bah" may mean something for an Arab, who speaks Arabic, but not for an American muslim who cannot speak Arabic.
(I don't know which language you mean :S)

And I think you need to look at the bigger picture here:

The Olympus King said:
Drakexx said:

The Olympus king said:

Is there some new races or warriors?

Click to expand...

no

Click to expand...

bah!

He merely expressed his feelings towards the fact that there are no new races.
I don't think any harm was intended... :/

Edit:
English -> Arabic:

Bah \Bah\, interj.
An exclamation expressive of extreme contempt.

You're right, but in common English it just means you're not happy with something (and otherwise he could be punished for not speaking in English and for swearing

).
But the Arabic meaning just doesn't fit in this case :/

Eldubs · Jan 4, 2011

Sorry, he was making it look the other way. And as muslim i mean muslims, i live in finland and most muslims usually use this so called curse word. My apologies.

The Olympus king · Jan 11, 2011

Eldubs said:
If olympus is a muslim bah is a curseword.

YEP!I'm christian.

Eldubs · Jan 11, 2011

The Olympus king said:
YEP!I'm christian.

You dont need to yell it...

The Olympus king · Jan 18, 2011

Eldubs said:
You dont need to yell it...

okk.

-Kobas- · Feb 9, 2011

2 things why map shouldn't be approved!

- No creeps on starting locations!
- 3 gold mines on starting location is epic fail (just try to play with night elves)

As soon as you fix this I will approve map!

Ironside · Jun 28, 2011

-Kobas- said:
2 things why map shouldn't be approved!

- No creeps on starting locations!
- 3 gold mines on starting location is epic fail (just try to play with night elves)

As soon as you fix this I will approve map!

Review by Ironside
----------------------

Positive features:

/

Negative features:

/

Additional Information / Conclusion:

Changes weren't made.

Rating: /
Vote for: Rejected

Swamps Of Sorrow v1.0

Swamps Of Sorrow v1.0 (Map)

Moderator

Moderator

Similar threads