BTNSacredSword

[Moderator]

19:39, 9th Aug 2009
oh_snap: Can't honestly see anything wrong with it. Recommended.

 

[Palaslayer]

subscribing

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Well, that's one excellent icon. The handle doesn't suit it though. :/.

 

[Somnium]

Ohh shiny.

Review coming pretty soon, but first i need to practice some karate. One thing I will say though now, the handle isn't symetrical.

Edit: Maybe you can post the big picture so i can give a better review ?

Edit2: The Review Strikes Back xD

Well first i would like to say i didn't notice the pixel saying fuck you. Hmm, maybe you make it moree define ?

Good:
1. Sword blade has great highlights
2. The other highlights are well placed accoring to the light source
3. The light source is well chosem
4. The background is fitting.
5. The icon is very usefull.

Bad:
1. The handle isn't symetrical, which makes it look a litle weird.

Rating 5/6

 

[Palaslayer]

you've forgotten to say that i shall remove that single px in the top right corner that says FUCK YOU!

-.-'

 

[Amigurumi]

looks nice, but what's with background?

you've forgotten to say that i shall remove that single px in the top right corner that says FUCK YOU!

well, yes, you should remove it

 

[PsychoNerdial]

Looks very good^^ 4,5/5

 

[Latecat]

Simple, yet well made.
4/5.

 

[Licheus]

I agree. It looks good, but if something should be changed then it's the handle.

 

[Panda]

Hmm, sword looks a bit small, considering the handle is a bit big and the details are both it are bit big also. I would say too re-size or re-shape everything.